News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rock Band. Guitar Hero. Why They Are Doomed. by steveklabnik on Wednesday August 26, 2009 @12:20PM (#787451)
As someone who played competitive Guitar Hero...

It's not that it's "Doomed." It's that it got really, really popular all of a sudden, and that spike is dying down. Rhythm games are a genre that's lasted quite a long time. It's not going anywhere anytime soon.

Re:Rock Band. Guitar Hero. Why They Are Doomed. by ALee on Wednesday August 26, 2009 @02:19PM (#787734)
I would love to hear from everyone who has loved, previously loved, or played any rhythm music games. Our startup JamLegend.com is focused on innovation in the space and have a couple of ideas. Would love to get your honest feedback on the industry in general (your favorite games) or on our site. Rant here or feel free to email me at Andrew [] jamlegend.com

Completely agree with Steve though that rhythm games will be around for a while and there is still a lot of room for innovation. GH sales have dipped, but that's why they're expanding their game selection.

Re:Rock Band. Guitar Hero. Why They Are Doomed. by unalone on Wednesday August 26, 2009 @09:59PM (#788470)
Andrew:

You're fighting a losing battle with the "spontaneously generate beats based on a user-selected tune" thing. A part of what makes rhythm games fun are how cleverly each song is programmed. I've tried Dance Factory and AudioSurf, and they are simply no fun without a guiding creative hand.

Re:Rock Band. Guitar Hero. Why They Are Doomed. by dolinsky on Wednesday August 26, 2009 @05:36PM (#788119)
Andrew, I love jamlegend, but until the Flash hiccup bug can be solved once and for all, it really throws a dagger in my rhythm-playing abilities.
Re:Rock Band. Guitar Hero. Why They Are Doomed. by chipsy on Wednesday August 26, 2009 @12:49PM (#787539)
Agreed. This post is overly dramatic. Genre fads come and go, and the rhythm-action genre has seen a good long run with very, very little innovation(you could even say "reversal of innovation" given that the current crop of games actually tend to have fewer gameplay features than the Bemani games of seven or eight years ago.)

In a few years or so, I'm sure some developer will come up with the answer for reviving the genre. Until then, we have other things to play. It's that simple.

Re:Rock Band. Guitar Hero. Why They Are Doomed. by kevindication on Wednesday August 26, 2009 @01:14PM (#787587)
I think you're right. My supporting observation: I can't seem to find reasonably priced used controllers on craigslist.
Re:Rock Band. Guitar Hero. Why They Are Doomed. by steveklabnik on Wednesday August 26, 2009 @02:58PM (#787811)
To be fair, the controllers are usually of pretty shoddy quality. I've broken, repaired, and re-broken almost every piece of GH and RB equipment I've owned.