Substantively: why should the previous behavior of the reporter matter one bit? If someone does something bad, whether a person complaining about it is "good" or "bad" is sort of besides the point, and digging into how evil that person is amounts to an all-too-transparent attempt at deflection. Shanley, for better or for worse, takes advantage of that to generate news. That means that even if you get provoked, external observers won't and shouldn't care enough to get caught up in whether Shanley's a bad person or not. (Your takeaway, by the way, should be "do not engage" because she's communicating with an audience that's not-you when she engages with you. Also: all comments on this story amount to engagement, hence the heavy flagging.)
My sympathy for the fired guy is very limited. He clearly fucked up, and immediately knew it and took it down (before she even posted her screenshot, it seems), either because a friend told him he was out of line or he realized it himself. Which does elicit a bit of sympathy from me, and if I were in her shoes, I'd have let it slide--there's more than enough misogyny in tech than to need to scrape the bottom of the barrel here. Despite that, he did fuck up. Freedom of speech is not an issue: if he had posted a long stream of tweets calling for Jews to be slaughtered, no one would be upset that his company let him go. She has just as much freedom-to-report-speech as he has freedom-to-insult-speech, and freedom of association is an equally important right.
I think the main point is the precedent that Jon Snoeder tweeted about. This isn't to just punish the fired guy. It's to set an example to everyone else about what would happen if you are out of line.
If someone is actively baiting people on the basis of gender, it should have equal consequences regardless of the speaker's gender.
> My sympathy for the fired guy is very limited.
I never said he shouldn't have been fired. I think the problem is trolls can provoke people to the point they get fired and the trolls suffer no repercussions which is a point I should have made clearer, my apologies.
That also presumes the trolling is as bad as the offense, I don't think it is.
It's realpolitik my friend, if you don't engage trolls you can't be bitten by them.
Pointing out a troll's hypocritical behavior seems to be the only one that is effective with both trolls and rational people.
The only winning move is not to play. Completely ignoring them.
Which eludes to my original point of why one would engage with them... what did he hope to accomplish?
I'd like to see equal, proportional response regardless of gender or the size of your soapbox.
> Which eludes to my original point of why one would engage with them... what did he hope to accomplish?
You'd have to ask him that :/
I certainly don't agree with that logic in general. If the offense was valid (which I don't think it is in your specific example), I am fine with offenders reporting other offenders. For example, I am fine with a murderer turning in another murderer.
An example relevant to HN is:
https://twitter.com/shanley/status/474601030986903552
"HN is fucking obsessed with me lol. what is wrong with you little boys? mad cuz i'm cute and would NEVER talk to you or know you exist?"
Yet, this person is still able to get an employer to fire one of their employees for engaging in the same behavior she does.
Is it just me that feels people who attack people on the basis of their gender shouldn't be able to get people fired for doing the same thing?
Edit: I was trying to say the consequences should be equal. I probably should have said the reverse in my question at the end there since it seemed to lead to confusion. [e.g. Both should be fired since consequences should be equal for equally bad behavior]