News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Troubled welds on the Bay Bridge by Shivetya on Monday June 09, 2014 @09:59AM (#7868444)
I am trying to understand how this fiasco is any different from Boston's big dig? Are we just posturing because it was a Chinese company? Neither was bid/priced right and both have/had safety problems.

Welcome to the world of government contracts, big projects tend to be vastly different than what is proposed or agreed too.

Hence I am confused as to why the controversy this time.

Re:Troubled welds on the Bay Bridge by dandelany on Monday June 09, 2014 @12:21PM (#7869101)
So your argument is, because government projects are usually problematic, we should not be calling attention to new problematic projects? Doesn't that seem a little... fatalistic?
Re:Troubled welds on the Bay Bridge by Shivetya on Monday June 09, 2014 @01:36PM (#7869436)
I am not aware of many if any actually big government projects that are not problematic. However I do think the story was full of underhanded/indirect Chinese bashing, if not just plain foreigner bashing; like the quote "unaccustomed to the rigor of American construction rules". I guess they are just too stupid to do business in the real world, and this in the state that wants to waste billions on a train to nowhere.

Frankly I am amazed at how much oversight there isn't on billion dollar plus projects. You would think there should be more than one agency, in particular neutral non government agencies that should be required to sign off on projects that crest a certain dollar amount.

This is not to say that big government projects are all bad, they do lay ground work for many private companies to build on. Look as Space X, it would not be where it is today if not for NASA but it is a better choice for many things that NASA because of its big government mentality are not good at anymore. We only have to look at the recent boondoggle that was the ACA's main website to understand that oversight by non politically aligned, no government groups, is warranted.

TL;DR.

Yes, a lot of China bashing going on, to redirect the ire from its rightful spot, inept government with no real oversight. There needs to be "civilian" oversight on large government projects, appointed by industry experts.

Re:Troubled welds on the Bay Bridge by masomenos on Monday June 09, 2014 @11:51AM (#7868984)
Are you implying that there wasn't controversy over the Big Dig? I remember plenty.
Re:Troubled welds on the Bay Bridge by jusben1369 on Monday June 09, 2014 @12:29PM (#7869133)
I read the article as having a strongly anti Chinese bias. So I think Shivetya's point was a fair one which is "Should this be a story on government mishandling of big projects" as the lead and move away from the Chinese bashing? Or is there a legitimate angle for the overall story about the fact the cheapest bid also happened to be a Chinese company.
Re:Troubled welds on the Bay Bridge by Mtinie on Monday June 09, 2014 @12:42PM (#7869191)
The communication problems detailed in the article, coupled with the pre-construction work that was completed in China and then shipped across the Pacific, makes a difference when it comes to the management of the project.

That's not to say that these are unique problems because the contracting firm was Chinese, rather than, say, French. However, in this case it is relevant to the overall narrative that the challenges exist, because they make it that much harder to proactively address quality deficiencies.