The second reason is that those large private corporations like to make profits so disable a second gene to make sure the plant can't reproduce by itself. In other words the biggest ecological disaster is rampant spreading of the plant which is a commercial disaster for the corporation as well.
Don't assume that the food you eat today is at all natural. It has been transformed in ways you don't expect, e.g. wheat is a 3 genome plant. Those transformations at time had humongous ecological impact.
That is, the extra genes already fit into one very complicated system, the plant itself.
(I don't think this point settles anything, but a seed that manages to mature has passed a pretty stringent test)
Do you have any scientific argument against genetic manipulation?
The line of thinking behind this type of question always strikes me as either incredibly naive or purposely misleading.
There is a gaping hole in the way we sometimes wield our scientific approach to these things. On one hand, we say that a thing (such as ill-effects of GMO crops) must be observed, measured and quantified in order for us to accept that it exists. The fallacy enters when we then state categorically that in the absence of such evidence, the thing does not exist.
The presumption is then that virtually anything is safe until proven otherwise. Human history is literally filled with applications of this logic that ultimately proved harmful and even disastrous. Yet, we go on repeating this process and scratching our heads over questions such as, "why is x health-problem on the rise? Why is y animal dying?"
And, when we inject such flawed logic into something as complex and interconnected as nature, we are literally begging for unintended consequences--the ecosystem and all that. Someone else on this thread suggested that we solve this problem by engineering hardier milkweed. I think that pretty much says it all.
I am not saying that GMOs are without benefit or even that its risks or too high for those benefits. It just strikes me as both arrogant and short-sighted that we presume to know that the risks are worth the benefits, simply because we haven't yet proved otherwise.
What's frightening is how far and wide you need to search to find comments like yours. Most are simply mindlessly perpetuating one side or another of the artificial polarity:
"You 'hate' GMO, so you hate science" vs "GMO is evil, without any merit"
Childish, tiring. It has also begun to fracture society into more factions, more extremes. It's time for us to grow up.
My opinion is: GMOs are most likely a very useful tool, however the people in-charge of the direction appear to lack the emotional maturity to handle the greater responsibility. Until better people are in the driver's seat, we should proceed with extreme caution (which we are not doing).
I'm still trying to find common sense in his or your comments.
You don't want GMO because you don't trust big companies even if you don't know what GMOS is used for. That argument is not common sense, is just ignorance and bias.
Can both of you just provide ONE scientific reason against GMO, and no, GMOS are not just crops.
So, how many years must something being observed before saying that is safe? 20 years, 100 years, 1.000 years?
Are you saying that GMO insulin is not safe?
> It just strikes me as both arrogant and short-sighted that we presume to know that the risks are worth the benefits, simply because we haven't yet proved otherwise.
Can you explain why after more than 30 years of observation not finding adverse effects is just short-sighted and arrogant ?
>Are you saying that GMO insulin is not safe?
To the extent that you've addressed my point at all, you've helped to make it. I mean everything is safe until it isn't right?
And, this is the part where I respond by offering some evidence that you contest, thus again declaring all GMOs completely safe.
But, the irony of your response doesn't appear to have occured to you, so let me ask you a question: is it your claim that everything that was declared safe after some "acceptable" period of observation has ultimately proven to be so? If not, then what could possibly have gone wrong in our conclusions?
Feel free to think beyond GMOs if that helps you to see more clearly.
No, this is not my point.
> And, this is the part where I respond by offering some evidence that you contest, thus again declaring all GMOs completely safe
Where I have declared all GMO's completely safe?
> is it your claim that everything that was declared safe after some "acceptable" period of observation has ultimately proven to be so?
No, this is not my claim
> is it your claim that everything that was declared safe after some "acceptable" period of observation has ultimately proven to be so? If not, then what could possibly have gone wrong in our conclusions?
No, my claim is that using your argument we can't use anything because in some distant future we can find that it is not safe.
I ask again, how many time we can wait until we can use some technology/medicine/etc
> Feel free to think beyond GMOs if that helps you to see more clearly.
I'm not thinking in GMO's
>my claim is that using your argument we can't use anything because in some distant future we can find that it is not safe.
Nice try. You're waffling and trying to make this discussion about me. You initially demanded scientific evidence of harm caused by GMOs. The clear implication is that without scientific proof of harm, concerns are not credible. The natural corollary is that they should be considered safe.
The point I made is simple: we cannot assume safety simply because we have yet to find evidence otherwise. This is what you (and others) are doing when, as a tactic for dismissing concerns, you repeatedly demand scientific proof of harm.
I'm not sure why that statement is controversial, but yours is the same approach that pharmaceutical, tobacco, chemical (etc.) companies have employed over decades. Under this model, they merely need to demand evidence, then point to some doubt in findings of harm in order to continue touting their wares as safe. The burden of proof is on the claimant and, worse, even reams of empirical evidence are frequently insufficient for this purpose. Look how long tobacco companies were able to fight in spite of mountains of evidence against their product.
If you want to ignore decades of history and pretend to actually believe that companies with a vested interest in denying harm do not do so, then feel free. But, at a minimum, you should not express bewilderment that right-thinking people respect the scale of what's at stake, have the temerity to express doubt, possess the common sense to consider their observations, and ask questions.
"respect the scale of what's at stake, have the temerity to express doubt, possess the common sense to consider their observations, and ask questions."
.. pretty much sums it up, though some will try to dismiss it (I can't imagine a valid counter-argument to that). As far as the 'philosophical' aspect behind this debate goes, that may be as clear as I've yet seen it written.
It would be helpful if others passionate about this subject would read this. Perhaps learning to avoid the 'anti-science' mines planted all around this topic that childishly squash any intelligent discourse or debate.
The point you make is moot when you won't believe the evidence even if it kicks you in the butt.
GMO has been investigated not by your evil companies but by universities and scientists by decades.
You don't like GMO, fine. But don't hide your dislike with that bullshit. Even if they ares studied for centuries, people like you will say that we don't have sufficient evidence.
When you can find a single scientific argument against them, call me, until then, it is just ignorance.
By now, I don't expect you to see that irony.
Which begs the question: Are you a GMO scientist, or are you going on trust too?
Yes. You cannot do proper science if you're motivated by profit to rush it to market, to hide bad results, and to not give a fuck about properly investigating long term consequences.
That it's based on technology (the technical ability to do something) and not deep scientific understanding of it.
>Do you have any scientific argument against genetic manipulation?
Did they have many scientific arguments against thalidomide?
History is, of course, replete with such examples. Thalidomide was actually a "fortunate" case to some extent, because the degree and the immediacy of the harm done enabled relatively swift acknowledgment of the causative agent.
But, your parent seems unable or unwilling to understand how his line of reasoning produces such short-sighted outcomes. Instead, he continues to exemplify the very problem by repeatedly demanding evidence for harm, and assuming safety until such evidence is provided.
It's pefectly circular reasoning and is especially dangerous in cases wherein a causative agent is not readily identified or works within a complex, multi-variable system such as nature.
Again.
The vested interest is often a sign of an unreliable claim; I would argue back that GMO-haters have just as much (more) vested interest in hanging SOME crime on GMOs, and are too willing to believe anything bad said about them.
Let's make a bet. I'm going to mix a vat of chemicals. Then, I'm going to tell you that it's safe and "prove" it to you by feeding it to a mouse and, together, observing it go "unaffected" for 15 minutes. Next, I will challenge you to prove that it is unsafe. If you cannot provide some "plausible evidence" that it is unsafe, then you will drink a gallon of my concoction every day for a year. Do we have a bet?
Simplification? Yes. But, the line of reasoning is the same.
Of course I don't believe every unsubstantiated claim. That's a straw-man. And, I won't contest your point about whatever vested interests GMO-haters may have in "hanging some crime on GMOs". Instead, I'll object to your implicit characterization that the issue is binary. The world is not just comprised of GMO-lovers and GMO-haters. Some simply hold reasonable concerns. In fact, I don't recall even stating in my comments that GMOs are unsafe. I've only said that we don't know that they are safe; yet we often behave as if we do. We then challenge others to prove otherwise as a condition of constraining their use, even when we've seen this approach end in disaster time-and-again.
That's my point.
It is only the same reasoning in your imagination
Well, we do know that companies can throw science to the side and rush to push products to market. They can even pay researchers for favorable studies (tons of tobacco industry sponsored studies back in the day, showing how smoking was a-ok).
We also know that GMOs have vested interests of trillions of dollars, from companies such as Monsanto.
The "vested interests" of GMO-haters are what? At best their ideology -- which is not a tangible interest.
All the GMO development is done by evil multinational companies?
> Did they have many scientific arguments against thalidomide?
Thalidomide was retired after just 4 years of its release, GMO has been investigated for 30 years
Are you really comparing those two things?
Do you really have any argument or do you will repeat the same "companies are evil" without anything more? And without taking into account the research done by universities and not the fucking companies?
My question: What makes you think the corporations (including the scientists) understand the complex systems they're interacting with well enough to warrant altering the path of many million years of natural development. What makes you think they even care?
For the record I'm a software developer for 30+ years, even a mildly large/mature piece of software is undeniably complex - and must be treated with serious regard to the larger interactions - never mind nature.
I wouldn't charge such a thing to private corporations, the hubris is undeniable. Please change my view here.