News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Turing Test Success by acchow on Sunday June 08, 2014 @11:40AM (#7864938)
> The first school of thought believes that AI can be achieved by mimicking real conscious beings

It's important to note the true meaning behind this school of thought - that mimicry and "true" intelligence are actually equivalent. Behaviorists believe this, and the validity of the Turing Test along with it.

Re:Turing Test Success by swombat on Sunday June 08, 2014 @12:20PM (#7865043)
I think it might actually be in Civ5 that I first heard the following quote:

"Asking whether a computer can think is about as useful as asking whether a submarine can swim."

I think this is fairly insightful and relevant.

Re:Turing Test Success by marcosdumay on Sunday June 08, 2014 @01:21PM (#7865233)
That's from Djigstra.

I digress. Most of the times, mimicking Nature works very well. We tend to always remember our most spectacular failure, but that's a selection bias.

Re:Turing Test Success by Houshalter on Sunday June 08, 2014 @04:01PM (#7865697)
Cars don't run like horses, solar panels don't use photosynthesis, engines don't work like muscles, computers don't look like biological neurons, etc, etc.
Re:Turing Test Success by andreasvc on Sunday June 08, 2014 @05:52PM (#7866037)
His name is Dijkstra. I'm curious how you arrive at the conclusion that mimicking nature works most of the time, do you have some examples?
Re:Turing Test Success by marcosdumay on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @12:26PM (#7878851)
Looks like the post is too old, and I can't correct it anymore. On my defense, I was quite tired when I wrote it.

You don't have to go very far looking for examples. The fictional Nautilus submarine was named after the animal Julio Verne copied its depth control system (the same one all real submarines use till today). Also, the first submarines' shape copied whales, a design that was adapted (but not completely replaced) because it does not work as well witout also copying their propulsion system.

By the way, birds wings are better than planes ones in several important ways (but worse in a few others). We don't copy them because we don't have good enough materials, not because it's not a good idea.

Re:Turing Test Success by andreasvc on Sunday June 08, 2014 @05:58PM (#7866053)
The wording of your comment reveals your bias towards the other school of thought, Strong AI. But what is "true" intelligence? I don't think anyone has a clear definition of this, and in reality it's all just a philosophical quagmire. An important distinction is whether mimicry is equivalent to "true" intelligence, or whether it should be treated as such, barring a better litmus test. With that in mind, taking a methodologically agnostic perspective of adequately reproducing behavior that is predicated as intelligence seems like a much more reasonable goal to me.
Re:Turing Test Success by Sami_Lehtinen on Monday June 09, 2014 @04:14AM (#7867455)
Strong AI wouldn't make same silly mistakes which people make all the time. So would the Strong AI need to be smart enough to play dumb to fool people? Because people are illogical, smart machines surely wouldn't be?
Re:Turing Test Success by andreasvc on Monday June 09, 2014 @06:05AM (#7867693)
A Strong AI is by definition more intelligent than humans, so it could also deceive. No need to "be illogical", just playing along. In any case it's rather irrelevant, because presumably if there is a Strong AI, it would be so impressive that there is no need for a Turing test to prove it.