News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Noam Chomsky: A Surveillance State Beyond Imagination Is ... by smoyer on Sunday June 08, 2014 @08:47AM (#7864545)
Describing Obama: "the constitutional lawyer in the White House"

The question that this brings to mind is whether Obama agrees with our constitution's precepts. Wouldn't a constitutional lawyer be the perfect person to circumvent or destroy its intent? In much the same way a person that understands the internal workings of a lock is the best one to pick it?

Re:Noam Chomsky: A Surveillance State Beyond Imagination Is ... by rayiner on Sunday June 08, 2014 @09:45AM (#7864650)
You can agree with the precepts of the Constitution and justify certain kinds of surveillance. Even if you think the NSA surveillance is unconstitutional, you have to concede that "privacy" is not a well-defined constitutional value. The framers spent many pages in the Federalist talking about the ins and outs of various voting systems, but never articulated a broader concept of privacy. The 4th amendment is based fundamentally on a "property rights" view: intended to keep the government from searching your property.

A perfect example is the recent case in Jones. Is it unconstitutional because putting a GPS tracker in a car enables 24/7 surveillance, or because it requires the police to physically trespass on the car to place the tracker?

The protection of "privacy" in the constitution has been extended to reach things birth control and abortion based on the "penumbras" of the rights that are actually in the text. This is fuzzy ground! You can believe that those penumbras exist yet still not believe they cover recording information people put out into the public internet.

In short, its not so much that Obama is well-placed to know how to work around the Constitution, its that he knows that digital privacy is on unsure Constitutional footing in the first place and is positioned to take advantage of where the lines are drawn.

Re:Noam Chomsky: A Surveillance State Beyond Imagination Is ... by alexeisadeski3 on Sunday June 08, 2014 @11:22AM (#7864876)
"The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized."
Re:Noam Chomsky: A Surveillance State Beyond Imagination Is ... by rayiner on Sunday June 08, 2014 @12:40PM (#7865100)
Key word: "their." The lynchpin or a lot of the surveillance efforts is accessing information that doesn't belong to the target of the surveillance. Phone call metadata is generated by the phone company, stored in the phone company's computers, and is used for the phone company's business purposes. Its the phone company's data, not yours. Same thing with the data Google and Facebook collect about where you go on the internet. You didn't generate it and you can't even access it. How can you say its "yours?" Its "about you" but that's totally different. If your neighbor keeps a diary tracking your comings and goings, you can't assert 4th amendment protection over that data.

Privacy advocates talk about "metadata is data" as if the government's lawyers don't understand that bits are just bits. What privacy advocates don't understand is that the "metadata" distinction is about generation, ownership, and control, which are implicated in the 4th amendment by the word "their."

Re:Noam Chomsky: A Surveillance State Beyond Imagination Is ... by foobarqux on Sunday June 08, 2014 @01:13PM (#7865201)
Putting aside what the law and constitution currently say, do you think mass surveillance of metadata, URL tracking and search history should be fair game?
Re:Noam Chomsky: A Surveillance State Beyond Imagination Is ... by rayiner on Sunday June 08, 2014 @04:56PM (#7865879)
I'm pretty apathetic to the whole issue. I'm a lot more worked up about the fact that these things are already fair game when it comes to private corporations. As someone who isn't hoping for some libertarian, trans-national world order based on the internet, I'm a lot more worried about how private companies can abuse that data than how the government can do so. Yes, the government can throw me in jail and private companies can't, but the government has little reason to want me in jail. Meanwhile, private companies have a lot of incentive to access that data and screw me over.

I think the libertarianness of the whole digital privacy movement is losing a lot of potential supporters. If the restrictions on government surveillance were bundled together with restrictions on corporate surveillance with a consumer protection angle, I think you'd get a lot more people on board.

Re:Noam Chomsky: A Surveillance State Beyond Imagination Is ... by foobarqux on Sunday June 08, 2014 @05:23PM (#7865958)
> but the government has little reason to want me in jail

It has plenty of reason to want dissidents in jail which you may care about for various reasons both practical and ideological. Though I think jail is outmoded: with (near) total surveillance there are more effective deterrents.

I do think you are right about the lack of emphasis on corporate surveillance.

Re:Noam Chomsky: A Surveillance State Beyond Imagination Is ... by alexeisadeski3 on Sunday June 08, 2014 @05:19PM (#7865944)
Google and Facebook would also be protected by the Fourth, were it actually respected.
Re:Noam Chomsky: A Surveillance State Beyond Imagination Is ... by mpyne on Sunday June 08, 2014 @12:15PM (#7865026)
Why does everyone simply quote the Fourth Amendment as if that answers the question about privacy, especially privacy as applied to electronic communications?

Let me quote the Supreme Court decision establishing a right to privacy [1] (which was not previously considered present!): "Secondly, the Fourth Amendment cannot be translated into a general constitutional 'right to privacy.'" That Amendment protects individual privacy against certain kinds of governmental intrusion, but its protections go further, and often have nothing to do with privacy at all."

The decision goes further to note: "But the protection of a person's general right to privacy -- his right to be let alone by other people -- is, like the protection of his property and of his very life, left largely to the law of the individual States".

In other words, one may have statute protection, but not blanket Constitutional protection. And that opens up the possibility of the ones writing the statutes carving out "foreign intelligence" exceptions.

And this is all in accordance with the decision to invent the "reasonable expectation of privacy", it's not even going into later decisions like Smith v. Maryland which tended to expand government search ability.

[1] http://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/389/347

Re:Noam Chomsky: A Surveillance State Beyond Imagination Is ... by alexeisadeski3 on Sunday June 08, 2014 @05:17PM (#7865936)
The Supreme Court has long ago abandoned any interest in protecting the rights defined by the Constitution.
Re:Noam Chomsky: A Surveillance State Beyond Imagination Is ... by beerbajay on Sunday June 08, 2014 @10:24AM (#7864725)
> agrees with our constitution's precepts

The problem is that not even the members of the Supreme Court can agree on what these are or how they should be interpreted.

The everyday understanding of constitutional law is not the same as the legal understanding, which is part of the problem. The commerce clause, as read by any normal individual would not allow the Federal government to have anything to do with (e.g.) pot, but that is how it has been interpreted by the supreme court. No normal person would say that corporations are people, but according to the court they are. etc etc etc.

Reading the constitution, I get a clear picture of a federation of independent states. But this idea died after the Civil War, if not before.

Re:Noam Chomsky: A Surveillance State Beyond Imagination Is ... by rayiner on Sunday June 08, 2014 @10:34AM (#7864748)
Commerce clause says that the federal government shall be able to regulate interstate commerce. Pot is something traded in intestate commerce. Its not as ridiculous as you make it seem. The framers might have used narrower language if they could foresee that one day, everything would be a part of interstate commerce. That certainly wasn't true during the time of the framing, when goods were produced locally or even primarily by the individuals using them on family farms. But they used broad language with the intent of giving the federal government the power to regulate large scale commerce as it existed then.

The Supreme Court didn't say that corporations are people. It said that people don't lose their first amendment rights because they assemble themselves into a corporation. Falls naturally out of the first amendments rights to free speech and assembly.

You can't ignore the civil war. The 13, 14, and 15 amendments were a renegotiation of the Constitution at the point of a sword. The idea of a federation of independent states is called into doubt by the supremacy clause and commerce clause, which was in the original, and the 14 amendment, which allows Congress to legislate directly against the states to enforce the amendment. Moreover, looking at original intent, the federalist faction of framers wanted a strong central government. They didn't give states autonomy because they wanted to, they did it because they had to, and they set the stage for states becoming secondary powers.

Re:Noam Chomsky: A Surveillance State Beyond Imagination Is ... by curt on Sunday June 08, 2014 @11:20AM (#7864869)
The Commerce Clause was put in place to stop States from taxing each other, not what it's currently being used for.
Re:Noam Chomsky: A Surveillance State Beyond Imagination Is ... by hga on Sunday June 08, 2014 @11:28AM (#7864898)
Expanding on this, the utterly vile 1942 Wickard v. Filburn (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wickard_v._Filburn) held about someone growing wheat for his own consumption, quoting Wikipedia:

The Court decided that Filburn's wheat growing activities reduced the amount of wheat he would buy for chicken feed on the open market, and because wheat was traded nationally, Filburn's production of more wheat than he was allotted was affecting interstate commerce. Thus, Filburn's production could be regulated by the federal government.

So growing and consuming just about anything locally falls under this interpretation, because otherwise you'd buy it in a market that crosses state lines.

Re:Noam Chomsky: A Surveillance State Beyond Imagination Is ... by mpyne on Sunday June 08, 2014 @12:18PM (#7865033)
Well, that decision was also conducted under the aegis of a wartime America with a President that actually did have much more expansive Article I powers due to the nation being in a state of war.

I could be hopelessly optimistic and naïve but I simply don't see a similar argument holding in a decision today since there's no National Food Board (or whatever the agency was) to set rationing levels or resource priorities for wartime industrial production.

Re:Noam Chomsky: A Surveillance State Beyond Imagination Is ... by hga on Sunday June 08, 2014 @12:24PM (#7865050)
Except the case preceded the war except in its winding its way through the courts, it's New Deal law, after the "switch in time that saved nine" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Switch_in_time_that_saved_nine... from later in the Wikipedia article on the case:

"In July 1940, pursuant to the Agricultural Adjustment Act (AAA) of 1938, Filburn's 1941 allotment was established at 11.1 acres (4.5 ha) and a normal yield of 20.1 bushels of wheat per acre. Filburn was given notice of the allotment in July 1940 before the Fall planting of his 1941 crop of wheat, and again in July 1941, before it was harvested. Despite these notices, Filburn planted 23 acres (9.3 ha) and harvested 239 bushels from his 11.9 acres (4.8 ha) of excess area."

Re:Noam Chomsky: A Surveillance State Beyond Imagination Is ... by mpyne on Sunday June 08, 2014 @12:24PM (#7865051)
If they meant to limit it only to keep the states from taxing each other then that's exactly what would have been in the Constitution. For instance Art. I. Sect. 10 is very clear about how states may impose duties and tariffs on imports/exports, it was very much not left to chance.

Knowing the intent of a given clause is helpful for the courts in determining how to interpret the law or Constitution when the written text of the same is unclear. But when the Constitution or law is perfectly clear then that's what the law is.

In this case the relevant clause is "The Congress shall have the Power to regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and among the several States."

That's it... unlike Art. I. Sect. 10, there are no specific constraints or restrains embedded there, certainly nothing about taxes (since it would be easy enough to simply declare that states could not tax each other, similar to how Art I. Sect. 10 does it).

Re:Noam Chomsky: A Surveillance State Beyond Imagination Is ... by beerbajay on Sunday June 08, 2014 @10:48AM (#7864781)
> Pot is something traded in intestate commerce

Sorry, I should have specified that I meant "grown for private consumption". Obviously if it crosses state borders it fits with what the commerce clause was designed to regulate.

Re:Noam Chomsky: A Surveillance State Beyond Imagination Is ... by throwawayaway on Sunday June 08, 2014 @09:01AM (#7864572)
In 2005 he did, but he's pretty duplicitous in retrospect:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ylVOdriEyA

So he's no longer the perfect person to do so.