News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Things that make Go fast by stcredzero on Saturday June 07, 2014 @01:29PM (#7862543)
Go is almost as fast as Java. Which is to say Go is respectably fast. They should get kudos in the language developer man hours metric. Considering how new they are, how few people have worked on the language, and the results achieved, the result can be counted as an accomplishment.

It's a small and elegant way to achieve a particular pragmatic result. That always deserves respect in my book. (The JVM deserves it too for slightly different reasons.)

Re:Things that make Go fast by seanmcdirmid on Saturday June 07, 2014 @01:45PM (#7862583)
There is a difference between gold stars and empirical results. Go is fine enough as a language, but it can't claim any performance crowns, you can't describe how go is faster than Java when it's not.
Re:Things that make Go fast by stcredzero on Saturday June 07, 2014 @02:35PM (#7862686)
Go is fine enough as a language, but it can't claim any performance crowns, you can't describe how go is faster than Java when it's not.

Did I miss something in the reading? I didn't see the claim that Go is faster than Java. Speed isn't everything, and the rabble that don't have the wherewithal to know that and that Java is quite a fast managed language don't matter. Take it from an old Smalltalker. (Who remembers the days when Smalltalk VMs were kicking the JVM's butt, but people still thought it was 1985.)

Re:Things that make Go fast by seanmcdirmid on Saturday June 07, 2014 @05:40PM (#7863187)
That is the weird part of the essay...they talk about why Go is faster than Java, without mentioning that it really isn't.
Re:Things that make Go fast by stcredzero on Saturday June 07, 2014 @07:29PM (#7863451)
[Citation Needed]

Just re-read it. Again, I didn't see anyplace where it's actually said that Go is faster than Java. I can see many places where someone touchy and defensive might take it that way, however. Either the apparent knee-jerk reaction is a deliberate attempt to troll by creating a false argument, or it's simply a cringe worthy false argument worthy of a Picard meme.

Re:Things that make Go fast by seanmcdirmid on Sunday June 08, 2014 @03:24AM (#7864189)
A blog post talking about why to use Go...for performance...and here is how it is better than Java about performance, even though it's not really better than Java. I don't care about Java, my language of choice is C#, but this smacks of the worst kind of anti-logic promotion. It seems to be quite endemic in the Go community also.
Re:Things that make Go fast by stcredzero on Sunday June 08, 2014 @09:17AM (#7864592)
Again, is this a deliberate troll, or is it intellectual sloppiness? The post talks about why Go is fast. There are memory footprint comparisons. AFAICT, There are no language speed comparisons.

There is only text that a genuinely touchy and defensive person or a troll might misconstrue. Did someone steal seanmcdirmid's HN password?

Re:Things that make Go fast by seanmcdirmid on Sunday June 08, 2014 @11:45AM (#7864955)
If one talks about why Go is fast, and then compares techniques against other languages ANYWAYS, what the heck is the reader supposed to think? In an academic paper, this would be torpedoed right away: you aren't allowed to take the 5th if you want to beg the question.
Re:Things that make Go fast by stcredzero on Sunday June 08, 2014 @02:09PM (#7865358)
If one talks about why Go is fast, and then compares techniques against other languages ANYWAYS, what the heck is the reader supposed to think?

That a short discussion of language feature implementation techniques is provided as a point of comparison with regards to different types of overheads?

In an academic paper, this would be torpedoed right away

Well, since I read "this" in the context of this sentence as an assertion imagined by you and unsupported by facts, then yes, you are obviously right. That would be torpedoed. Note that it's not a product of who you thought it was.