This isn't strictly a reply to jawns, but it's on a related topic that I've wondered about.
Fifteen years ago, such instantaneous, ubiquitous communication was very rare. I went through college without having instant notification of anything whatsoever, as did pretty much everyone I knew at the time.
Babysitters ran into issues fifteen years ago; there were bugs in websites fifteen years ago; there were critical emails being sent out fifteen years ago, but nobody expected constant, instant feedback because it was implausible, and everyone was okay with that.
Are our problems today really that much more urgent than they were then, that we truly need to be constantly connected? Or is this imaginary, and since we in theory can respond instantly, people now expect that we must?
The question is if I'm paying for a lecture is it reasonable for them to mandate my own non-disruptive activities in lecture. I don't think so.
We also need to consider that professors are egotistical creatures (as all humans are), so they're going to oppose anything that detracts from the perceived value of their work. What's the balance here between improving student welfare and making professors happy?
Life changes. If people don't like that, there are still some very nice remote forests they can go live in.
I guess I still retain the wondering, though; with possible response times reduced to effectively instantaneous, are we losing anything? Is it good that anything we are doing can always be interrupted by something else?
And if it is really so critical, they can send text message on your muted phone and you will have to leave the lecture anyway.
I'm not saying I want to ban laptops, just that your examples are very unconvincing. I get it, the class is very low priority to you, but if you are going to regularly fix bugs or write emails and then ask other to fill you in, you will be disturbing to others.
I'm glad you didn't work for my campus newspaper.
Several other people have echoed your comment that these are things that you can just as easily handle on your phone. But I think that misses the bigger point. If a professor can ban laptops, he can ban phones and tablets and all other communication devices.
My overarching point is that devoting 100% of one's attention to a college lecture is not only not always necessary, but in some cases, not desirable; there are legitimate reasons why a student attending a lecture may want to receive communications, and legitimate reasons why he may wish to respond to those communications immediately.
How many emails do you really get that are so urgent that they couldn't wait an hour? Why can't your babysitter text you (or, just IM on your smartphone)? Why are you the only person who can fix said critical bug (if it's fixable through the CMS, others should be able to handle it, if not, well, why are you running such terrible infrastructure when there are dozens of mature platforms?).
Also, for things that are legitimately small and quick, it's surprising what you can get done with an SSH client on your phone - if it needs more than that, you're likely going to miss the rest of the lecture anyway, so why not leave?
If it was a business meeting in the sense of meeting with someone external to the organization, that might be different, but internal meetings are very laptop-oriented.
I can understand not letting high school students use phones, but in college you are an adult with sometimes conflicting responsibilities.
But seriously, are you so incredibly important that you cannot spend 60 minutes listening to a lecture?
This generation (and yes I know that includes me) seem to have an incredibly inflated sense of self-worth, as if they're the centre of the universe.
It's like those idiots who can't stop texting in the damn movie.
The world will keep spinning if you don't answer that tweet for an hour - trust me.
I had this exact same argument with a friend last week when we went to a three-hatted restaurant, and she insisted she needed to check her phone every few minutes, because apparently people would "panic" if they couldn't get in touch with her via chat.
Surely if you're paying $200 for a dinner, you can at least enjoy the dinner and company around you without needing to tweet every 5 minutes.
fail the course.
Some are even known to demand everyone place their phones, very much powered off, in a box on their desk at the start of class.
In contrast, with college students, I don't think it's unreasonable to think that -- at least occasionally -- a student may need to "check out" from a lecture momentarily to deal with some pressing business, even if it means that he has to spend time later asking a classmate to fill him in on what he missed.
For instance, maybe I'm in class, and I get an extremely important email and need to send an immediate reply. Maybe I'm a working-adult student and my babysitter has just IMed me. Maybe I manage the campus newspaper's website and someone just sent me a report of a critical bug that I need to deal with right away.
This is all the sort of stuff I encounter regularly in the working world, and I don't think it's unreasonable to think that college students encounter it, too.
Being able to keep open a laptop to deal with things like this is a lot less distracting than having to step outside the lecture hall to take an urgent phone call.
Yes, putting away the laptops might slightly increase students' abilities to soak up the material, but (sorry, professors) sometimes the class you're sitting in is not your top priority, and sometimes that's OK. I occasionally had to skip class to chase down a hot story for the school newspaper, and I don't regret it a bit. So long as the student is using the privilege responsibly, I say let 'em keep the laptop open!