Re:The case for banning laptops in the classroom.
by DanBC on Friday June 06, 2014 @04:47PM
(#7860203)
The people in the meeting should be participating in the meeting.
The meeting needs a fast and accurate note taker to shorthand or type what everyone is saying and distribute those notes.
That leaves you free to make the important notes and mark your action points. (This can be paper or laptop).
Re:The case for banning laptops in the classroom.
by mathattack on Friday June 06, 2014 @05:31PM
(#7860372)
Is the optimal situation where everyone can see what the note-taker is writing? Has anyone done this?
To stay engaged, I've used the scrawl now and type later method, which means the notes never get out early enough. They do allow me to reflect on them though.
Re:The case for banning laptops in the classroom.
by Htsthbjig on Friday June 06, 2014 @06:16PM
(#7860535)
The problem with laptops is keyboard noise.
Compare note taking with keyboard typing in a class with several dozen people and you will see noise is a big problem if you are the teacher.
I personally believe the best solution is audio record anything the teacher says, automatically transcribe it and just draw diagrams and stuff.
But it will take some time before people start doing it.
Re:The case for banning laptops in the classroom.
by existencebox on Friday June 06, 2014 @08:37PM
(#7860876)
I realize this is one of the "better" examples, but it's certainly close to home for HN, but would you really argue that recorded audio and drawn diagrams are more useful for CS/algorithms courses than some typed snippets and pseudocode? That was at least where having a laptop in class really paid off for me.
Re:The case for banning laptops in the classroom.
by BruceIV on Saturday June 07, 2014 @06:35PM
(#7863325)
Different people process information differently; for me seeing an abstract diagram of say, a B-Tree, would be more useful than a pseudo-code overview of the structure (at least first - the code might be useful once I had an grasp of the idea from the diagram). That's just me, though, different people learn differently.
This overly rambly anecdote should serve to illustrate not that I think laptops are "the right answer", but getting rid of them unilaterally will really harm those who actually have learned to incorporate them into a useful workflow. Why not address some more root causes, e.g. why engagement is so low? Facebook doesn't "force" you to browse it, and maybe I'm acting snoody in this, but there are certainly classes that I wouldn't be caught playing my favorite video games during for the subject matter being so interesting.