Chat rooms have a place for small communities, but I fear that they simply don't work for larger ones without more internal structure. But maybe you don't intend Chapp to be a tool for discussions at that scale. Regardless, good luck with your project.
Frankly, you could be very right about our approach potentially getting jammed-up just due to the lack of structure. We're still not clear on what's going to happen here, and do consider it an experiment. Although Chapp isn't in any way groundbreaking (it's closely informed by many other formats) we see it as something that could perhaps be a bit of a "new twist."
Of course, in building something you don't entirely understand, yet, it's hard to say if you're making the right choices. For example, I would have thought Twitter's 140 character limit was an obstacle, but I think it actually worked to their advantage by allowing for faster, easier interaction for those with something to say but not enough discipline to create longer-format content.
From what we've seen during our first week, I think we might be on to something. Early users seem to like the simplicity of the approach, and a few are really taking to it. That said, we could be misreading this entirely. If nothing else, though, it's been fun so far, and we're curious about where it goes from here.
And thanks for the well wishes!
Reddit seems to work just fine, and I find it a good way to find new stories and fun content.
That said, I also find the overall structure sort of difficult to navigate/process. (This is my personal reaction—others might feel completely different.)
I'm not so sure that Chapp is really going up against Reddit. That said, I think we're trying to approach this in a somewhat (visually) simpler fashion.
Additionally, I think Reddit comes from a more granular standpoint of "here's a thing; discuss," which for the most part seems probably better than the vague nature of channel driven discussions. But, I think the notion of a broad topic with less focused conversation might have certain advantages as well.
I suppose this isn't that clear of a response. (Perhaps I should blame this on a long day and a couple of glasses of wine.) I think, though, that these are just sort of different things, even if they seem similar on the surface. I suppose in time we'll see if that's actually the case.