News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:High Frequency Trading and Finance's Race to Irrelevance by goodcanadian on Thursday June 05, 2014 @04:01PM (#7854000)
HFT provides liquidity . . .

I always see this argument. Market makers provide liquidity, and yes, HFT often act as market makers. However, I am not at all convinced that the high frequency element adds anything useful to the equation. I don't care whether my trade executes in a microsecond or a second. In fact, I often leave limit orders open for DAYS in order to get the price I want. I am also not convinced that most HFT are truly acting as market makers.

I think the most charitable thing that can be said about HFT is that it narrows the spread. In order to make it worth their while, the HF traders then have to make a lot more trades. Whether this is adding any real value to the system is harder to say because while the spreads are smaller, the volatility is higher.

Re:High Frequency Trading and Finance's Race to Irrelevance by tptacek on Thursday June 05, 2014 @04:37PM (#7854237)
It doesn't make much sense to challenge the liquidity provided by automated market-makers while conceding that they reduce spreads; spreads are essentially a proxy measurement of liquidity.
Re:High Frequency Trading and Finance's Race to Irrelevance by goodcanadian on Thursday June 05, 2014 @05:13PM (#7854562)
I didn't say that they didn't provide liquidity; I said that I am not sure that the additional liquidity they provide actually matters to anyone other than high speed traders.