How would this even work? Understanding Market micro structure is literally my day job and I'm having trouble parsing your proposal.
Consider the market where I want to buy at a limit of 9.90 and someone else wants to sell down to a limit of 10.00.
What price would the exchange set? People have already said the maximum the market will buy for is 9.9 and the minimum the market will sell for is 10.
if there is no overlap you just cant' trade no matter what the exchange does.
Today the price is the price at which the last transaction happened.
I am proposing instead that the price is set and updated by the exchange, and transactions only happen when they can execute at the exchange price. And the exchange price moves at a preset rate - down if there are outstanding sell orders, up if there are outstanding buy orders, else still.
So in your situation the price would wind up somewhere between 9.9 and 10, then stay indefinitely until another order began moving the price.
Basically for someone placing an order you're losing the ability to trade instantly, and gaining the prospect of trading at a possibly better price. Therefore you don't need a pool of people trying to give you instant trades.
How does HFT change that?
Now the spread is 8 cents. Anyone who wanted to buy can now buy it at a penny cheaper than an instant ago and the opposite holds true for anyone wanting to sell.
Isn't this only true if you measure price stability based on amount of changes in the price, but not magnitude of those changes? How can they lower the spread but simultaneously decrease stability?
Furthermore to me HFT looks like stealing because it is very inefficient relative to the need. If exchanges were to reorganize how they work slightly, we would get much better price stability, somewhat less liquidity, and have a much lower premium.
The necessary change is simply this. Exchanges would have to set a price at which orders are to execute. Whenever there are excess orders in one direction or the other, that price would drift up or down, slowly, until the order executes. The result is that trades might take a minute to execute, but margins would be far less. Sure, a ton of finance people would jump up and down screaming bloody murder about how many of their complex trades would be affected. But my opinion is that that economic activity takes a lot of brains and resources, and doesn't significantly add to the purported purpose of finance - to make money available to companies engaged in useful production.