News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: how to deal with revisionism? by jacquesm on Tuesday August 25, 2009 @10:58AM (#784967)
There is nothing inherently dangerous about healthy debate, nobody pushed you into the revisionist camp, you simply made a claim that is - lets put it delicately - not mainstream.

Germany is still coming to terms with their part in all this and that is why they are over reacting, another big factor is that there is a definite surge in the numbers of neo-nazis.

The funniest thing is that some of the extremist rightwing people (notably Wilders) are best friends with Israel, I never really understood that one.

The revisionist bit comes from taking up the position that you think that because it happened before your time must mean that you have to be unsure about it because of a so-called lack of evidence.

The evidence is there for everybody who wants it to see it, no 'belief' is required.

Clever people in the revisionist camp abuse the basic insecurity people have about things that happened before they were born to push their own agenda forward, and with some success. Which is why you get the reactions you are seeing.

My parents and grandparents lived through the war in Europe, one of my grandfathers was sent to a work camp in Germany but fortunately survived, lots of people they knew were less fortunate. I know personally plenty of people where the whole family tree is balanced on a single survivor that made it - miraculously - out of one of the 'death camps'. To me it's all pretty real and very close to home.

Re:Ask HN: how to deal with revisionism? by Tichy on Tuesday August 25, 2009 @11:22AM (#785017)
"nobody pushed you into the revisionist camp, you simply made a claim that is - lets put it delicately - not mainstream."

I think you just did push me into the revisionist camp. I did not make a claim, except that there are people who deny the Holocaust. I also say that I personally can not verify it, but that is not making a claim.

Merely taking up the discussions means that you will mention arguments of the revisionists, which will end up making you look like a revisionist. Having a question about the HC makes you a non-believer.

Re:Ask HN: how to deal with revisionism? by jacquesm on Tuesday August 25, 2009 @11:34AM (#785042)
> Having a question about the HC makes you a non-believer

I did not see you ask any questions, only state your doubt.

> I also say that I personally can not verify it,

Yes, you can. Find some camp survivors and have a chat with them, then wonder how we will remember when the last ones have died.