Because the car would still rely on its regular
rechargable lithium-ion battery most of the time and
would switch to the aluminum-air battery as a backup only
if the lithium-ion battery ran out, and because most car
trips are 50 kilometres or less, Alcoa estimates the
aluminum-air batteries would only need to be changed
about once a year.Think how much lighter the Volt would be with no gasoline engine!
And they also don't mention if you can choose how much to lug around. Maybe I think I'll only need 500 miles of extra range a year and I can carry around a pack half the size? I'd do that, even in the fast-charge plentiful northwest. It would be nice to have the freedom to skip a station and make some time instead.
The BMW Rex is so close to perfect, that I think a lot of people are getting it with the hope that maybe they will be able to swap in a larger tank somehow later down the road. The tank right now isn't even 2 gallons. It's pathetic, and done to get some kind of damn sticker in California, not for any practical reason. Make that a 6-gallon tank with some after-market solution, though, and you've got a car with an 80-mile electric range and then several hundred more miles on gas for road trips.
I didn't know that the Volt has a mechanical connection from the engine to the wheels. For some reason I thought it was also a pure series design.
The most important part for me for electric cars is the simpler power-train system which is less likely to break... which is why i would never buy an hybrid that has both systems.
https://autos.yahoo.com/blogs/motoramic/car-dealer-scientifi...
http://www.forbes.com/pictures/ehmk45iidj/toyota-prius-2/
http://editorial.autos.msn.com/18-most-dependable-cars-on-th...
http://www.edmunds.com/car-reviews/best-used-cars-2013.html
http://wallstcheatsheet.com/automobiles/10-most-dependable-c... (This is the one without a Prius, but even this one has a hybrid on the list in the form of the Volt.)
Anecdotally, I seem to see a disproportionate number of the original Prius on the road still, despite only selling 54,000 of them in the US, and being over a decade old at this point. That could, of course, just be confirmation bias or local demographics.
Where metal-air batteries could have a place, is as a trickle charging device that will be replaced only rarely, perhaps during an annual checkup, and used as a backup only on the few occasions where fast charging is unavailable or unwanted. But battery vehicle companies are onto this idea already - the Tesla Model S has space for what some suspect is in fact an upgrade slot where a metal-air trickle charging battery can be installed.
The problem is, most mainstream news articles writing about progress in battery-electric vehicles are already far behind the state of the art. Tesla's innovation and execution in this space has largely removed range anxiety for all but a small (<5%) number of trips, and already have a very strong quick charging presence in multiple countries. The future is electric and is already here - most people just haven't noticed.