Re:Ask HN: how to deal with revisionism?
by reedlaw on Tuesday August 25, 2009 @10:06AM
(#784831)
Whenever there are rational proponents on both sides of a controversial issue I tend to view the "official" position with at least some degree of suspicion, especially when there are politics involved (e.g. global warming, vaccinations).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
But why? Your attitude is one of the reasons I tend to view the opposing opinion with suspicion, because I suspect many people only choose that faction because it is the "being against it" faction and the underdog.
Because there may be an underlying political interest in maintaining the "official" position. For example, if anthropogenic climate change is "fact", and not just a theory, then legislation such as cap and trade may be easier to pass.
Also, when people adopt an unfashionable or non-PC position they are more likely to experience ostracism and even persecution. That would seem to be a significant barrier to entry into these "opposing factions".