How does a difference in the level of intelligence of a particular entity compare to the effective intelligence of having lots of less intelligent entities? Having lots of people means that you can apply intelligence towards a lot of tasks, but perhaps all of them together will never come up with something that a greater intelligence could come up with.
Thinking about it, it seems to me that you have to apply it against an actual difficult task. Take a task like "build a power-producing fusion reactor" that nobody knows how to do yet. Would we be able to figure out how to do that faster if there was some superior intelligence applied to it? Or does the huge number of engineering problems associated with building such a thing respond better to a large number of more ordinary intelligence?
Sorry for reviving old thread.
edit: And the collective is significantly more intelligent than the individual (for some but definitely not all reasonable definitions of intelligent and collective).
Only in the sense that Stalin or Pinochet was a productive citizen. Powerful people can mobilize others to their own ends without those ends being at all good or moral for everyone who is not so mobilized.