NLP is hard
An AI could form _a number of_ inferences and then use a knowledge base to choose a likely candidate. In fact: I feel like IBM's Watson gave us a little preview of what an AI's "thought process" might be like.
If the system knows Curly drives a red lambo, and that it is a rare car in this area, and that Curly usually only parks in the parking lot when he's around, and etc. etc. etc.
He was outlining that the difference is: humans do not need the context.
I do not know who Curly is, and I still got what car he drives just by reading the three-line dialog.
I inferred that too, but it doesn't mean that it is correct.
Not saying that parsing natural language is easy, just not sure this is such a terribly hard example (for a system that's prepared to cheat and/or appear stupid/gullible).
Eg, parse both the above and the below correctly with the same parser:
Ann: Have you seen my dragon?
Dad: I think he is playing with the bear in your room.
Ann: Ok.
(Personally I'd be happy if a system thought Ann had a dragon, but CIA analysts might be less than enthusiastic)