News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by homakov on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @05:04AM (#7838851)
Why does government set N hours at all? It's must be up to business! E.g., if I have a software company, I want my employees to work 20 hours a week. Isn't it obviously better way for everyone?
Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by vidarh on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @05:20AM (#7838917)
When it was left up to business, we had 14 hour+ days. It took many decades of extensive strikes and demonstrations, during which dozens of workers were killed, before the 8 hour day became the norm.

The US union that is now the AFL-CIO leadership in pushing for the 8 hour day led directly to making May 1st the international day for labor demonstrations, in part in commemoration of the Chicago Haymarket Massacre.

If you want your employers to be able work less, nothing is stopping you most places. But experience is that not having an upper bound caused employers to take massive advantage.

Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by codehotter on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @05:59AM (#7839078)
You seem to know a lot about this and it's something I've always been interested in:

When laws were passed to mandate 8 hour work days, what % of companies had 8 hour work days already? 10%? 20%? 80%?

Nowadays we know that total productivity is higher if you have 8 hour work days, even though you work less total hours, because your productivity per hour is much higher. Was something like this known at the time? Or was the push to 8 hour work days only so that people could spend time with their family? What kinds of arguments were used?

Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by jacquesm on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @06:08AM (#7839110)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eight-hour_day

Is a good read on the subject and the referenced links are even better (as usual). The 12 hour workday had to be fought for... that tells you something about what %age of employers had 8 hour workdays already, left to their own devices that percentage would be very close to 0. Each and every reduction in hours had to be fought for somehow.

When I was an employer in Canada and we had the standard NL holiday/compensation package our employees were so happy, and other companies nearby cautioned me not to be too open about it lest it 'would spread' and their employees would demand similar. Employers do not tend to be on the same side as their employees in arguments like these (though they should be: happy employee = loyal employee).

Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by vidarh on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @06:15AM (#7839144)
Pretty much nobody had 8 hour work days. One of the earliest known instances of someone demanding, and getting, an 8 hour workday was a English-born settler in New Zealand, who worked as a carpenter. In 1840, he negotiated an 8 hour working day for some building work, and he started arguing for it with other workers:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samuel_Duncan_Parnell

Here's a PDF that gives some stats from 1890 until the 1930's: http://www.nber.org/chapters/c4124.pdf

Prior to the 1890's, it took decades to even get down to the 12, and then 10 hour workday.

I don't remember specifically when there started being actual research into the productivity effects of shorter work days, but it definitively was not known at the outset - at the outset, it was driven by workers rights movements.

Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by vacri on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @06:40AM (#7839211)
The 8-hour workday predates the modern idea of time and motion studies, so it's a bit hard to get those kinds of statistics in a meaningful context around productivity.

But for the sake of argument, the percentage would be very low, probably pretty much limited to professionals that could work their own hours. Most people were working poor, for whom the workday was 10-16 hours long, six days per week (in the Western world).

To give you an idea of the significant lenghth of prior work hours, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eight-hour_day has a pair of phrases: "Women and children in England were granted the ten-hour day in 1847. French workers won the 12-hour day after the February revolution of 1848."

Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by crazy1van on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @08:15AM (#7839612)
"Nowadays we know that total productivity is higher if you have 8 hour work days,"

We know? Surely on a planet with 7 billion people, some of them can maintain their work efficiency for more than 8 hours. What about the Steve Jobs and John Carmack's of the world? I don't see them being 9-5 people.

Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by vidarh on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @08:42AM (#7839742)
It is implicit that when we are talking about regulation of the work day, we are concerned with averages.
Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by dnautics on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @11:22AM (#7840715)
As a Lyft driver, I am more productive the more hours I work (I top out at 12 hours which I only do on weekends). So the 8 hour rule doesn't apply for everyone.
Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by dllthomas on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @11:34AM (#7840804)
I think your thesis holds, but I don't think it's clear that your example does (though it certainly still could). Depending on just how much chance of accident goes up over time, and just how great a "productivity" hit we apply for an accident, it is absolutely the case that your productivity falls at some point and it's conceivably the case that it's before 12 (or even 8) hours - though for all I know it's at 15.
Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by aestra on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @01:10PM (#7841431)
I'm sure the fatigue that sets in after (say) 15 hours would be a serious factor in accident risk. I mean truckers are required to stay under a certain work day/week and get enough sleep for safety reasons. Sure if they drove 24 hours straight they would get there faster and in theory be more productive but there are serious safety concerns both with the driver and with the truck (less time for maintenance or inspection)
Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by dnautics on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @04:59PM (#7848258)
agreed. My typical pattern on weekend nights is to sleep for 10 hours (yes 10 hours), do what I need to during the day for about two hours, and then get on the road, I'm usually taking anywhere from 1-2 hours of break doing other things that involve momevent (e.g. exercise, social dancing) within that 12 hours, as well, depending on availability.

During the week (when i work more protracted hours) I'm sleeping about 8 hours at least, and I'm also not beholden to an alarm, so I get as much sleep as my body needs. I think I'm probably one of the most well rested people I know, despite pulling twelve hour 'shifts' three days a week.

Obviously I'm more tired after I do the 12 hour shifts than during the week, but I haven't felt so tired that I was at risk of falling asleep on the road (which happened from time to time when I was in grad school).

Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by dllthomas on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @01:57PM (#7841737)
Yes, also relevant might be the difference between what is safe as a one-off (maybe you really can drive 20 hours safely in a day, if you're well rested beforehand) and what you can do sustainably day after day.

In principle, this is stuff that insurance companies should be on top of...

Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by VLM on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @10:51AM (#7840521)
That seems to have a peculiar and unlikely assumption that they would have produced less by working fewer hours, while almost all human experiences show those at the top of their profession rarely if ever got there by merely punching a timeclock more than the next tier down.

I will never be a world class ballet dancer or world class basketball player simply by putting in a little more time than the next guy.

Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by danielweber on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @01:27PM (#7841527)
It definitely depends on the field.

Plus, in certain fields, even if you are experiencing diminishing returns, you can still squeeze more value out of those additional hours than someone else can.

Imagine one Friday your company calls the law firm you have on retainer. The guy handling your case has already put in 50 hours this week and is only operating at 80% capacity. You are still going to get better work out of him than his coworker, because your guy has everything about your case stored in his head without reading any notes.

On the other hand, if someone was on some type of monitoring duty, where usually nothing happens but if something does happen it's very important that he make the right call (ie guard duty, nuclear power plant operator) I would want to split his work over many people.

Sometimes two 30-hour workers perform better than one 60-hour worker, and sometimes they perform worse.

Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by crazy1van on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @11:30AM (#7840770)
Yes more time won't make you world class, but I bet the world class ballet dancer and basketball players often put in more than 8 hours a day.
Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by aestra on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @01:12PM (#7841440)
Probably but at some point you get diminishing returns. The human body needs rest to recover.
Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by crazy1van on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @01:16PM (#7841469)
Absolutely. But I bet the world class athlete knows where that point is for themselves far better than a legislator.
Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by smileysteve on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @02:47PM (#7842039)
> What about the Steve Jobs

If Steve Jobs would have worked less, he may not have been removed from the Apple Board. If he had spent more time with his family, maybe the Lisa wouldn't have had the connotations that it had.

These are not conclusive, but they do point us in a direction.

Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by Kiro on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @07:23AM (#7839374)
Do you hate capitalism?
Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by collyw on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @09:36AM (#7845423)
I would love to see a society with genuine capitalism. One where when banks don't have enough money they fail. Where inefficient businesses are not kept afloat by "emergency low interest rates" for the best part of a decade. When a supermarket doesn't pay a living wage, then the state doesn't give them enough to make up the difference.
Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @09:38AM (#7845430)
That's easy, look to the past. There have been times these things didn't get done, right? The economy was unstable. People's lifetime savings were lost, millions struck into poverty, and generally massive suffering.
Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by vidarh on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @07:51AM (#7839493)
Of course not - a well developed capitalism is a pre-requisite for socialism.
Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by justonecomment on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @08:13AM (#7839600)
I'm curious. Do you actively shut your eyes and ears to avoid the other comments and reference links, or is it unconscious?
Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by homakov on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @08:09AM (#7839578)
I love capitalism, I hate socialism.
Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by vidarh on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @08:11AM (#7839591)
That's a meaningless statement without defining which form of capitalism and which form of socialism you are referring to.

I'm a marxist, and I hate many forms of socialism. Karl Marx hated many forms of socialism. He even devoted a chapter of the Communist Manifesto to ripping apart forms of socialism he didn't like.

Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by homakov on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @01:30PM (#7841548)
I love regular capitalism and hate all forms of socialism.
Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by diogenescynic on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @04:28PM (#7842522)
The thing is, socialism is all over America and people actually like it. I'm guessing even you. For example, the military, public roads, the police, public libraries, public schools, fire departments, postal service, garbage collection, public landfills, the FBI, the polio vaccine (Dr. Salk could have sold his vaccine in the free market and made millions and millions of dollars. Instead he gave it to the federal government to begin eradicating polio.), museums, public parks, sewers, the GI bill, public beaches, snow removal, street lights, Amtrak, NPR, USDA, FDA, the Census, and on and on.
Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by homakov on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @10:23PM (#7843694)
This exact "implementation" of socialism doesn't prove it does better job than capitalism would. FYI I'm Russian and you can imagine what communism was (it was hell). No need to remove socialism completely, just keep taxes less and let people work. Look at Singapore.
Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by MisterBastahrd on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @04:02PM (#7842388)
Sorry, this doesn't exist in the real world and never will.
Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by _delirium on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @05:13AM (#7838885)
In this case, it's exactly as you say: the employer has decided to reduce its employees' working hours. It just happens that the employer is also the government. The experiment in Göteborg discussed in this article involves only municipal employees: the city is experimenting with moving its employees to 6-hour work days, and seeing what effect there is on productivity, morale, and other such measures. There's no requirement that other employers follow suit.

I believe even the 40-hour week is not statutory. At least in Denmark (maybe the same in Sweden?), the basic parameters of employment (maximum working hours, overtime pay, minimum wages, etc.), are negotiated between the employer's confederation and the union confederation, rather than set by statute. However, since the unionization rate is over 90% and the basic parameters are set through overall framework agreements (applying to all workplaces covered by the confederations, not separate company-by-company negotiations), these negotiated agreements de-facto set the conditions at almost all workplaces.

The Danish switch in 1992 from 40-hour to 37-hour weeks, for example, was entirely through union negotiations, not done by legislation.

Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by vidarh on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @05:21AM (#7838927)
In the EU, all countries are bound by the Working Time Directive unless they have exemptions (I think only the UK has any major exemptions), which does not make the 40-hour week statutory, but does set an upper limit (with some exceptions) at 48 hours/week.
Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by Cederfjard on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @06:38AM (#7839206)
> At least in Denmark (maybe the same in Sweden?)

Yes, the same is true up here.

Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by levosmetalo on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @05:14AM (#7838893)
No, because business and employees are not in equal barguaining position. Business always have an advantage and in unregulated markets they are more than happy to take advantage of their power position.

On the other hand, you can see these regulations as a collective bargaining between employees and business. Individual employees have no negotiating power against any corporation, but they all together can elect a government that will have an upper hand there, so it's just market behaviours.

And no, what you said about 20 hours work week doesn't work like that. I believe that many employers would be happy to pay only 20 effective hours a week for a software engineers, but sorry, my workday consist of some time needed to concentrate, get in the flow, release some stress, let the brain work in the hammock time, and you also need to pay for this, since you won't get these effective 20 hours a week without these other 20 hours. It just doesn't work like that. Maybe I would agree to be paid only for 20 effective hours a week, but my rate in that case will easily go double.

Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by rayiner on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @10:20AM (#7840325)
If you've got a winner-take-all system, and a small minority is willing to work much longer than everyone else, you end up with a situation where most people work a lot longer than they would prefer to, because the penalty for working 20% less isn't 20% less income, it's a dramatic drop in income. It's just a specific instance of http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Race_to_the_bottom.

Work hour limits are a reasonable solution in a democratic society where the majority doesn't want to be beholden to the work habits of the minority. Although, such a society should expect that some of those long-working folks will emigrate to countries like the U.S. where they can get outsized rewards for working longer than other people.

Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by spacehome on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @05:16AM (#7838902)
In theory you have a point, but historically speaking, individual businesses have been quite reluctant to allow shorter hours than what prevails in society. Progress on this metric almost always comes from societal movements and government intervention.
Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by homakov on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @01:37PM (#7841602)
Lets set 40 hours as max and 10 hours as min. Now it is flexible enough.
Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by lilsunnybee on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @03:34PM (#7847625)
In the US there is no minimum as far as how many hours an employed person can work; in the US it's called part-time labor, but this also causes huge problems with underemployment and poverty wages.
Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by d55 on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @05:12AM (#7838882)
Then you'd have the 60 hour work week pretty quick.
Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by homakov on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @08:10AM (#7839582)
I'd quit. I'm a specialist and will easily find another job.
Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by Loughla on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @08:28AM (#7839676)
You seem not to understand the depth of that statement.

It's not that one company would have excess hours; all of them would. So, you would be free to find a new position. . . at another company with a 60 hour work week.

Look at the history of the labor movement. Those in power tended to abuse those that weren't; long hours, unsafe conditions, etc. Now, unless you work in a coal mine or foundry, we can count out unsafe work conditions.

That really leaves one other option. . . . . .

Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by homakov on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @01:35PM (#7841577)
This is so senseless i dont know how to respond. It is like saying legal guns will increase the crime rate because they can kill. Companies compete to get specialists (look at how many perks average startup or google offers). Low skilled jobs? Who cares about them.
Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by Loughla on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @08:39AM (#7845188)
You know, I spent all night pondering your statement, and I came to the conclusion that you're either incredibly sheltered and immature, or a complete ass.

First off, it's not the same. There is no, or very low incentive for gun owners to commit crimes; especially when compared to the possible consequences.

If there are no protections for workers, though, there is every incentive for businesses to abuse their employees. History proves this statement true. That is, of course, unless I'm just not aware of a number of businesses who willingly limited their abuse before the labor movement.

And yes, the average startup and google and other tech sector businesses offer good perks. . . . That is not normal for a majority of careers, you know that, right?

And this, "Low skilled jobs? Who cares about them." Is either one of the most terrible statements I've read on HN, or one of the best trolls I've seen; boy, oh boy, did it get me worked up.

That is a terrible way to live. Do you understand how much of your life relies on low skilled jobs? Do you buy your food from a grocery store? Do you shop for clothes? Do you purchase anything that you don't personally create? At some point, low-skilled workers interacted with the goods you purchase.

The attitude that the only reason people work low-skill jobs is because they aren't smart or capable enough for anything else is very, very immature and incredibly ignorant. Specifically, your attitude that they apparently deserve to be treated worse and (in the context of our conversation) deserve to be abused by their employer because of their low-skilled jobs is awful, just simply awful. You should be ashamed.

Re:Sweden’s proposed six-hour workday by Sharlin on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @12:06PM (#7840997)
And it's not just about abuse of power - 60-hour-workweek companites would simply rather quickly outcompete those that had 40 hour weeks, except in rare cases.