Re:The boy who stole Half Life 2 source code (2011)
by tptacek on Monday June 02, 2014 @05:56PM
(#7836731)
Chiming in as per usual to note that Swartz's own lawyer wrote in a blog post after the tragedy that he believed Swartz was unlikely to receive a custodial sentence of any sort even had he taken the case to trial and been found guilty. It was a non-remunerative computer crime by a first-time offender, both of which are factors considered by the Federal Sentencing Guidelines.
Note also that the press release algorithm just adds these up for all charges. In reality, related charges are grouped together under the Federal Sentencing Guidelines. If you are convicted on more than one charge in the same sentencing group, you are only actually sentenced for whichever one gives the longest sentence.
No, 7 years was not the best outcome. It was the worst outcome. It was the outcome if the judge decided to make an example of him. This is not the armchair perspective. This is the perspective of anyone who is familiar with the Federal Sentencing Guidelines, and how they are used.You could have been one of those people, if you had bothered to read Orin Kerr's incredibly detailed analysis of the law in this case that was cited in the comment I linked to.
Answered in the references I gave. Too bad you didn't read them. Up to this point, you were simply being willfully ignorant. Now you just being dumb. Defendants who have not dealt with federal charges before, and so have had no occasion to learn about the Federal Sentencing Guidelines and how prosecutor press releases are way overflow, will learn this as soon as they talk to their lawyer after being charged. The plea bargain offer for a few months sentence was on the table until the very end.