> I'm going by what the manufacturers say
Are you really? "Non-recoverable Read Errors per Bits Read, Max", say Seagate - that just means it couldn't correct, not that it couldn't detect there was an error.
> are you saying they are overestimating the error rate?
Perhaps not, as a general order-of-magnitude upper-bound on a marginal drive in poor conditions, but certainly if you're interpreting it as an average. Too many people would be seeing it happen way too often to keep quiet about it otherwise.
> Used to be you never got corruption, just success or fail
I wish :/
I'm going by what the manufacturers say - are you saying they are overestimating the error rate? Why would they do that?
> They were never such devices in the first place
No, I meant they would return false data instead of an error. Used to be you never got corruption, just success or fail. Now you have success, false success, or fail.