Re:The Cost of Not Understanding Probability Theory
by jerf on Monday August 24, 2009 @03:20PM
(#783008)
So, what's the alternative? Give up the concept of "fair coin" when trying to teach statistics? This seems unlikely to be a useful pedagogical move! How is anyone supposed to understand Bayes Theorum before they even understand probability?
Mathematicians have to be able to specify priors. Insisting they are unrealistic rather misses the point that the entire reason the phrase "fair coin" appears in the first place is an explicit acknowledgment of the unreality of the situation.
If you want to more rapidly move to a Bayesian system when teaching, I'd understand completely, but we still have to start with "fair coins" before we can get around to considering how to prove they aren't fair. (I will be first in line to say many school teachers, being generally poorly trained in mathematics, completely fail to understand this point, and correspondingly ask the "gotcha" question about "what's after 29 heads?" without fully understanding the issue themselves.)
Mathematicians have to be able to specify priors. Insisting they are unrealistic rather misses the point that the entire reason the phrase "fair coin" appears in the first place is an explicit acknowledgment of the unreality of the situation.
If you want to more rapidly move to a Bayesian system when teaching, I'd understand completely, but we still have to start with "fair coins" before we can get around to considering how to prove they aren't fair. (I will be first in line to say many school teachers, being generally poorly trained in mathematics, completely fail to understand this point, and correspondingly ask the "gotcha" question about "what's after 29 heads?" without fully understanding the issue themselves.)