Re:Ask HN: How bad is it to use a self-signed SSL certificate?
by digitalchaos on Saturday May 31, 2014 @03:14PM
(#7826944)
That's understandable and probably a good reason for startssl to build an automated revoke tool, for the sake of keeping their name healthy. However, I would be way more concerned about a company unwilling to pay a trivial amount of money to revoke a cert that was compromises due to their own choice in how they used it. The best CA in the world won't fix bad security incident handling of another company.
Sure, most of the complaining was due to the entitlement, but I'd be interested in a list of all the companies that complained about this and/or failed to pay for a revoke.
From a security perspective, however, I think you need to meet some minimum standards to remain credible as a CA, and I think at least being willing to revoke certificates that may have been compromised for free and very quickly is one of those standards.
I find it difficult to support retaining StartSSL certificates as trusted-by-default in browsers given their response to Heartbleed and the consequent relatively high probability that any certificate ultimately depending on them has been compromised.