I can imagine it being a grueling effort! Part of what has kept me away from using a classifier or any kind of 'neural network'-type solution is that the initial configuration always seems to be something of a shot in the dark, and tweaking the weights is a non-trivial process with, as you said, a lot of wait time. When it works, though, it has that wow factor that clients love. I give you all props for taking that risk and having it pay off!
The resulting program does not run in real time, it basically runs every few minutes to have a good look at whoever signed up since the previous run and then assigns a probability to each of the new accounts.
This still catches the bad guys long before they can get up to any mischief (they still have to verify their account) and does not get in the way of the speed of the forms processing during sign-up.