Re:Pollen: the book is a program
by mjf2 on Friday May 30, 2014 @01:54PM
(#7823097)
Does it have mathematical typesetting like Tex?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
This is the real kicker for some applications.
After all, Knuth didn't write TeX because he needed a typography solution, he wrote it because he needed a typography solution for mathematics.
All these years later, and TeX (with or without LaTeX) is far and away the best solution I know of.
As for the mass market: Word's typesetting of mathematics is terrible, as is the interface (for anything but the simplest expressions). MathML is an interesting idea, but has a long way to go on the actual typesetting, as well as being much more painful to use than LaTeX...
Mathematica has a pretty decent typesetting system, but it's not open source or free...
True. When last I looked it wasn't quite competitive with TeX but still pretty good compared to, say Word. But it is also a niche system.
I've read about "experimental partial MathJax support" or something like that in the changelog, but I haven't looked into it, yet.
It's actually one of the big questions I'm having, as well.
Re:Pollen: the book is a program
by mbutterick on Friday May 30, 2014 @03:58PM
(#7823672)
You can use MathJax inside Pollen today. As far as building more integrated support for math typesetting, I'd like to do that, but what I'm not sure about yet are the ergonomics. Ideally, you'd just be able to drop TeX-style math expressions into the markup, indicating whether they're inline or block, and Pollen would do the right thing in terms of handling the rendering (based on whether the output is a web page vs. something else).
How do you think about MathJax vs. pre-rendering formulae to images and using those, with the TeX input as the alt attribute? Oh, and using STIX or whatever as web font.
There is already a couple of packages for Racket that prerenders formulas in TeX into various graphic formats (they call LaTeX to the rendering). It is straightforward to use these from Pollen.
I know that it's straightforward, I'd like to hear about pros and cons I haven't found myself.
If you want an html-page that works offline, then MathJax is rather large. In that case it makes sense to generate pdfs or svgs containing the formulas. Otherwise using MathJax from a CDN is quite convenient. On mobile rendering a page with many formulas via MathJax is somewhat slow though.
knitr does this reasonably well for letting you drop LaTeX directly into R reports with a delimiter... if you haven't seen that might be worth a look at the interface in some examples (e.g. http://yihui.name/knitr/demo/showcase/)