If an 18 year old decides he wants to get into programming and then realizes he wants a deeper understanding of computer science, then he should look into a college degree or classes.
We have it backwards. College should be for people who know exactly what they want to study/do, not for people who have no idea what they want to do.
Perhaps we (folks who went to college/uni) also push it down 18 year old throats because of an unconscious need and desire to feel that our college education was and is in fact important and valuable. Think about all those ever increasing number of doctorates and advanced degrees that NEED students to justify their expense obtaining...
> not for people who have no idea what they want to do.
Most people just want to make "more" money so they can afford more
EDIT: BTW, I believe everyone really needs to evaluate whether college makes sense or not. It doesn't make sense for a lot/majority of people IMHO.
That much I agree with: you should know exactly what degree you want to get before you enroll. College is far too late to explore your options.
Based on my own experience, I disagree entirely. All the employers I've talked to would rather hire and pay more to the guy with 4 years of experience, hands down. I'm sure it depends on the job and the type of company, but 4 years is a huge head start. When the college student graduates, the guy who didn't go to college will be his boss.
Now, of course, the ideal scenario is to do both: get work experience and complete college at the same time. You might finish school a year later if you're taking fewer classes, but then you have the best of both worlds.
Ah, but that's not the question. You won't have 4 years of experience during the hiring process; you'll have 0, and no degree. In that situation, 4 years after getting hired, where will that put you relative to someone who gets a degree?
> And the answer to that is often "No, they aren't."
It's certainly possible to get a job in some fields (notably tech) without a degree. And if you work long enough, you'll probably get to the same point you would have with one. On the other hand, I'm quite willing to bet that the average salary of a 22 year old with a 4-year CS degree vastly exceeds the average salary of a 22 year old with 4 years of work experience.
The same goes for graduate degrees, especially for tech companies that have a technical job ladder (those where you can get promoted without becoming a manager): take a look at the starting point for new hires with various degrees, then take a look at the average work experience of people who worked up to those starting points.
When I first started considering graduate school, I actually ran the numbers for whether it made economic sense to pursue a graduate degree, and it most definitely did, by a huge margin.
I do, however, agree with the concept of selection bias here: college is as much a signal of who you already were when you entered as what you learned.