What we're seeing is that the brokers aren't very keen on having everybody and their brother coming by to check out folks, so it's a quasi secret type of information. That's the worst of both worlds.
By the way, I keep hearing that phone companies have already set up e-com sites for Law Enforcement to retrieve phone tracking records (which do not require a warrant) Punch in your department's credit card number, type in the guys phone number, and get a record of everywhere he's been. Pretty cool stuff if it's true, but, as I note, folks who do this stuff aren't very keen on letting the rest of us in on the action.
I find debating whether the ship struck the iceberg on the left-hand side or the right-hand side a bit of a distraction from the effort underway to board the lifeboats.
http://krebsonsecurity.com/2014/05/experian-breach-tied-to-n...
That's close to what Germany does, if I understand their data privacy laws correctly.
On the other hand I can imagine how it would go in the libertarian-style U.S.: "If statistical data analysis is outlawed then only outlaws will be able to crunch numbers!"
Er, they'll probably think up a better catchphrase. But I think you see the point, it's hard to enforce laws which are inherently unenforceable without massive intrusion.
Since I don't need private information about you to defend my life, I'm OK with that.
In a free-for-all, people would be aware of what was being collected and they would take action. In what we have now, the fact that the information exists, it's extent, and what happens to it remains secret. I say get it out there.
In fact, it's wrong that a person can sit in a far-away city and spend ten bucks getting all the information they ever wanted to know about my neighbor because he shared it freely online, yet that same type of public knowledge is not available to the rest of the neighborhood for free. Freely-shared information has always been assumed to be local in nature -- you share it with somebody you are in proximity to. This is a good thing: keeps you from over-sharing.
It's not a perfect parallel, but you'd think internet-savvy people should understand how hard it is to keep the cat in the damn bag!
There's a difference between trying to suppress published information and trying to prevent the collection of that data in the first place. The Streisand effect applies to the first of those.
And this is where the NSA/FBI will go to collect data in the future. If, miracle of miracles, we manage to get the government out of our daily lives, they'll just write NSLs to these guys and in one swoop pick up tons of information from dozens of sources -- including data about people we associate with, since no warrant will be required.
These guys were doing "interesting" things when I last looked five years ago. Who knows how bad it's gotten since then.
ADD: I've thought this thing through several times, and the only way forward I see is either outlawing any collection and aggregation of private data outside of that directly needed to provide service, not ads -- or making all information collected from any source publicly available to all. I don't see the middle ground. (Sadly)