Re:Analysis of Over 2,000 Computer Science Professors at Top...
by avar on Monday May 26, 2014 @08:28AM
(#7799454)
Aren't there areas of scientific research where people doing genuinely valuable research don't get cited at all except within a closed community? I'd imagine e.g. that a handful of researchers all studying some obscure animal species would have a high h-index but a very low PageRank.
Re:Analysis of Over 2,000 Computer Science Professors at Top...
by eegilbert on Monday May 26, 2014 @08:53AM
(#7799539)
An experiment that did just that a few years ago:
"Manipulating Google Scholar Citations and Google Scholar Metrics: simple, easy and tempting" by Delgado Lopez-Cozar, et al.
http://arxiv.org/abs/1212.0638
[edit: grammar]
Re:Analysis of Over 2,000 Computer Science Professors at Top...
by warrenmar on Monday May 26, 2014 @03:36PM
(#7801197)
"weaker" metrics can be useful, because you can understand it better. If I tell you a PageRank of an author is 3.452. That means nothing to me. If I tell you somebody's h-index is 18. That means they published 18 papers that got 18 citations each. The h-index is useful for comparing people in the same field. There is also a metric for journals called impact factor.
Re:Analysis of Over 2,000 Computer Science Professors at Top...
by Anon84 on Monday May 26, 2014 @02:38PM
(#7800946)
You can even do something similar at the city level and see which city is the most influential in Science (or physics in this case): http://www.nature.com/srep/2013/130410/srep01640/full/srep01...
PageRank is recursive metric in graph. In above case, if above 10 professors don't have any other links pointing to them, they don't get ranked higher. PageRank was designed to eliminate scenarios like above.
It's amusing that Google Scholar doesn't use PageRank prominently instead of these weaker metrics.