News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Are we using the final numeral system? by chewxy on Sunday May 25, 2014 @11:39PM (#7798575)
A bit late to the party, but here's what I wrote in my JavaScript book:

    Asides: Number Encoding
    This may be a bit of a strange concept to discuss in a book about JavaScript,
    but the numbers that we’re all familiar with is only one of many different
    kinds of encoding that exsits in the world.

    The numerical system that we encode our numbers with today came from ancient
    India, and was popularized by the Persians, hence the name Arabic-Hindu numbers.
    It is a positional system. For example, the number 15 represents 1 unit in 
    the tens position, and 5 in the singular position - essentially 1 × 10 + 5 × 1.
    Likewise, 314 is 3 × 100 + 1 × 10 + 4 × 1. This is read as 3 units in hundreds 
    position, 1 unit in the tens  position, and 4 units in the singular position
    There also exists numerical systems which are non-positoinal. Perhaps 
    the most famous example are Roman numerals. It’s also positional-ish, since 
    the position of the numerals are somewhat important for specific cases - 
    VI and IV mean very different things. The Mayan numeral system is another 
    example of a non-positional system, intermixed with a unary-ish system.

    Most positional numerical systems have somewhat evolved into the same state, 
    despite having different runes and conventions to represent the same thing. 
    But perhaps the greatest innovation to numerical systems is the representation
    of fractional numbers in a positional numerical system. It allowed us 
    to do really much fancier mathematics. However, as can be seen in the example
    with 1/3 above, representing a fraction in a positional numerical system is
    somewhat difficult.

    The reason why this section is even here is to function as a reminder to the
    reader that binary numerical systems used by modern computers are also 
    just another system - imagine it to be from another civilization, if you will
     - and not be intimidated by it.

     Speaking of fractions, the ancient Egyptians were one of the first civilizations 
    to use a fraction system (the Chinese were the other). Especially by modern day
    standards, it was a very interesting fraction system. The fractions used by ancient
    Egyptians are expressed only in terms of unit fractions
    - i.e. fractions with 1 as the numerator.

There was quite a lot of junk cut out from my book too about ancient chinese numerical systems - they had different numerical systems for different classes of people, and different numerical systems for different bases. And even had negative numbers!

Your question is actually a question of positional and nonpositional notation. I'm quite sure we'll stick with positional notations for some time to come, but uh, you never know about the future. For all we know, there could be a superior nonpositional system out there.

There are no comments on this comment yet.