The educational system isn't that bad in the US if you're in the right place. It varies a lot from state to state and between towns or even areas in a town.
Their complaints about the u.s. - poor quality teachers, poor funding even in wealthy areas, and a generally poor culture/attitude toward learning. Their complaint/worry about Europe is making sure that their child gets into the University track of education which isn't guaranteed here.
We're both arguing without hard data here, but I'll just give an outright "nope" to the above.
http://www.bbc.com/news/business-27314075
I want my own kids to have a good education, and would feel comfortable moving back to the US from that point of view. My biggest doubt from that point of view is that I want them to be bilingual in Italian and English, and there is no Italian language education in the US, so it'd be up to my wife and I.
And this was considered a top school in one of the most expensive neighbourhoods around.