There are also some interesting scale economics unique to logistics. It doesn't cost much more to deliver to two houses on the same street vs. one house. So as the density of your userbase goes up, your cost per delivery drops. That being said, scale advantages of local delivery do not approach the scale advantages of a wider network like UPS/FedEx. If delivery were the only aspect of the business, I agree that it would be very competitive
Although I do believe local delivery companies are defensible, they are not necessarily a winner-take-all business in every market like eBay or craigslist. Multiple delivery companies can coexist in a local market, each serving a distinct set of restaurants
BTW, this marketplace take wasn't the impression I got from the TC article.
What I found interesting is how Sequoia degenerated from funding AMD/silicon to funding food delivery and calling it "tech".
"The new service [UberRUSH] signals the company's expansion beyond local transportation and into the much larger world of urban logistics. And it's a savvy play for several reasons: The same back-end technology that Uber has built to track drivers and connect them to riders can easily be used to order and follow deliveries."
http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2014/04/08/w...
If these guys are growing at such a speed that they are selling $10M worth of food in 10 months, they are growing freaking fast.
Would you mind elaborating on that defensibility claim ("if you look at any of these local businesses, whether they’re Yelp, or Grubhub, or whatever… once they’re built, they’re defensible")?
Why wouldn't this be a race to the bottom where "courier as a service" companies will be lowering prices until competition has eroded profits completely?
(just to be sure, to clarify: I'm genuinely asking out of curiosity - I'm sure if you have both YC and Sequoia backing you, you have some excellent answers for this question)