News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Angry London cabbies attack Hailo taxi app office by anigbrowl on Thursday May 22, 2014 @04:09PM (#7786155)
Well, you can call a cab in London too. What the drivers are understandably pissed off about is that they spent 2 years developing the navigational knowledge to get people from A to B quickly, so they could get their cab license, and now these other people are competing with them without havign had to had to meet any particular standard to start doing so.

The London cabs aren't just a monopoly as in a lot of other places, they have a very strong meritocratic basis. I was extremely surprised when I came to the US and cab drivers expected me to know how to get to my destination. I said to one 'isn't that what I'm paying you for?' and his response was 'I ain't no computer buddy, find it on a map.'

Of course the problem for London cabbies is that cheap GPS makes 80-90% of their knowledge redundant, so their hard-earned skills have literally been automated away. However, there needs to be a better response to this from the tech community than simply dismissing those skills as worthless. After all, it would be foolish to dismiss the effort required to get a medical degree just because of the existence of WebMD. This is more complex than a simple monopoly/disruptive competitor situation.

Re:Angry London cabbies attack Hailo taxi app office by w1ntermute on Thursday May 22, 2014 @04:24PM (#7786263)
> What the drivers are understandably pissed off about is that they spent 2 years developing the navigational knowledge to get people from A to B quickly, so they could get their cab license, and now these other people are competing with them without havign had to had to meet any particular standard to start doing so.

No, it's not understandable at all. It's no different from Luddites destroying machinery that allowed unskilled workers to replace skilled ones. Progress might be a bitch (for the cabbies), but that doesn't give them the right to obstruct it.

Re:Angry London cabbies attack Hailo taxi app office by anigbrowl on Thursday May 22, 2014 @04:33PM (#7786305)
It is very different, because there were no laws requiring weavers to meet exacting standards of manual skill before atetemtping to make a living as a weaver. Of course, a a pracical matter a weaver without those skills would get no employment, but that was the market at work.

London cab drivers, by contrast, had to make a significant economic investment (as well as meeting character requirements like having a clean criminal record) in order to get a cab license, a requirement imposed by the government body responsible for transit oversight (Transport for London). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Knowledge#The_Knowledge

I find it quite reasonable that cab drivers question why standards should suddenly vary for other people such that they can offer similar service without having to meet any special requirements. This is not the same as an arbitrary monopoly grant like cab franchises in the US.

Re:Angry London cabbies attack Hailo taxi app office by blibble on Thursday May 22, 2014 @04:58PM (#7786488)
> London cab drivers, by contrast, had to make a significant economic investment in order to get a cab license

you think your average Londoner cares? all they want is a service that gets them where they want to go; a random guy off the street with a £150 satnav will do this 95% of the time without issue, for a lot less than the same ride in a black cab.

Re:Angry London cabbies attack Hailo taxi app office by hcho on Thursday May 22, 2014 @06:05PM (#7786862)
They will quickly start to care when the number of hailed rides increase 10 fold. Which will gridlock the streets and bring the city to a halt.
Re:Angry London cabbies attack Hailo taxi app office by danielweber on Thursday May 22, 2014 @04:54PM (#7786456)
There is probably a market for some of The Knowledge folks. Someone gets into a cab, announces their destination, and the cell phone in the back seat transmits his voice to The Knowledge person sitting in an air-conditioned office at a PC. That person then uses his knowledge and skills, combined with a live street map of actual traffic conditions right now, to put a path into the driver's GPS.

I'm hand-waving that this market would support maybe a quarter of the old positions for a while. It's probably time to restrict new entrants and let the current workers attrition out.