News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An open letter on feminism in tech by anildash on Thursday May 22, 2014 @02:07PM (#7785260)
You read the story of a range of women from across the industry, said you haven't had the experience these women have had, and then explicitly asked men for their opinions. See if you can figure out the bug here.

* "We have this problem with our iOS app."

* "I use Android and have never seen this. Any other Android users encounter this?"

Re:An open letter on feminism in tech by hkmurakami on Thursday May 22, 2014 @02:27PM (#7785413)
I came here to say something similar: that the same action or speech can/will be interpreted very differently based on a whole slew of factors, including gender, ethnicity, or just plainly being different people to begin with. What appears "okay" or "benign" or "in jest" can certainly not be the case for a colleague, whichever gender they may be [1].

In fact, I'd argue that it's hard to perceive the inappropriateness of our own actions in the moment. It's much easier to notice the possible auxiliary effects of our past actions when reflecting on them at a later time. Frankly, I can think of any number of things that I've said or done in the recent past that may have made my female friends and colleagues twitch an eyebrow, but didn't elicit an explicit response because they've learned to just deal with it and let it go, having been in a boys club for so long (one started her career in investment banking). And I'd consider myself to be fairly self-aware of these issues, and yet I've admittedly failed many times over.

edit: and frankly, how many of us voluntarily and regularly look back at our past week/month to think about the ways in which we've failed ourselves and our own principles in this area? We may review the ways in which we failed in our job capacity and reflect on how we can improve, but I think the frequency with which we do the same for our social interactions is much lower.

[1] In fact, I think "I was just kidding" is one of the lamest excuses for actions that at times clearly are not thus.

Re:An open letter on feminism in tech by Ma8ee on Thursday May 22, 2014 @02:56PM (#7785642)
Many women ask that more men would stand up for them. I think that many men would if they actually saw something occur, but many just don't see anything.

In my own career I have only once seen anything that even looked like harassment or discrimination, and that was almost 20 years ago. It does not mean that I question these women's experiences, but I do think it means that the "bullies" know that what they do isn't accepted by their peers. And hopefully that means that speaking up more when these things occur would make a positive difference.

Re:An open letter on feminism in tech by ankey1 on Thursday May 22, 2014 @03:11PM (#7785756)
Woman developer here. That's the one piece of advice I give to men who ask what they can do to help. I've had way more men come to me privately after an incident to apologize for being a witness and saying nothing than have actively stepped in to stop what was going on. I wish it were the other way around.
Re:An open letter on feminism in tech by mreiland on Thursday May 22, 2014 @04:28PM (#7786282)
why should they? I mean that honestly because context matters.

Why didn't you say something? Why should they be expected to step up and say something if you yourself are not willing to (was it a superior, for example?). Was there some brouhaha in which they sat silent while you had to defend yourself?

And why not ask them if you can submit their name to HR as a witness to the behavior instead of getting disappointed in them for not doing it themselves?

At the end of the day, the only person who is ultimately expected to stand up for you, is you. It's that way regardless of gender.

edit: I still don't understand why HN allows replies to some posts and not others, but to respond to the post below me.

Because it's unfair to ask a man to put themselves at risk protecting a women when she, herself, refuses to put herself at risk. This isn't about male vs female, this is about a person putting themselves at risk for another person, and the fairness of it.

This is specifically why I asked for context.

Re:An open letter on feminism in tech by gress on Thursday May 22, 2014 @05:16PM (#7786609)
So you don't care about injustice you witness and you don't want others to either?

Women already have less power because they are in a minority. It seems as though you want them to take responsibility for all cultural change.

It sounds as though you don't think there is a problem.

Re:An open letter on feminism in tech by mreiland on Thursday May 22, 2014 @06:42PM (#7787024)
I think expecting a male to put himself at personal risk for a women who won't put herself at personal risk is unfair.

We have no context, we don't know if the person in question doing the injustice was superior in the company, or not. All we know is person A did something bad to person B, and person C did nothing about it.

Why shouldn't we ask my person B did nothing either?

Re:An open letter on feminism in tech by gress on Thursday May 22, 2014 @07:31PM (#7787228)
Because there is a power imbalance.
Re:An open letter on feminism in tech by Ma8ee on Friday May 23, 2014 @01:42AM (#7788143)
I don't agree with mreiland about not sticking up, but I also want to point out something important that I get the impression that many feminists miss: That men in general have more power than women in general does not mean that all men have power, or that even most of them are in a position of power.
Re:An open letter on feminism in tech by gress on Saturday May 24, 2014 @03:24PM (#7794115)
This is true, but in a male dominated environment, there are usually men who have more power than women and if they don't use at least some of their power to support the cause of equality, they are supporting the status quo.
Re:An open letter on feminism in tech by mreiland on Friday May 23, 2014 @12:14AM (#7787946)
you think the male should put himself at risk of being fired because the female may get fired if she does it?

That's not equality, and I would defend anyone who stays quiet in such circumstances. Don't ask the random male to go to bat for you if you're not willing to do it yourself. Common sense.

Re:An open letter on feminism in tech by gress on Saturday May 24, 2014 @03:22PM (#7794104)
You're confused about what equality means. When a group has less power, they have more to risk.

You are staunchly defending the status quo, and insisting that all change is the responsibility of women.

Re:An open letter on feminism in tech by mreiland on Friday May 30, 2014 @03:22PM (#7823489)
No, everyone else is confusing an entire gender with a person.

It is not fair to ask person A to put themselves at risk for person B when person B is not willing to put themselves at risk for themself.

This isn't about gender, if it were two men, no one would blink twice at me asking why the software dev didn't put themselves at risk. But because we have a social expectation of protecting women, even by women themselves, people expect the male software dev to put themselves at risk for the female software dev, even if the female software dev is not willing to put themselves at risk.

Re:An open letter on feminism in tech by optimusclimb on Thursday May 22, 2014 @02:21PM (#7785369)
Anil - I'd have expected a bit less snarky of tone from someone so public, but I'll try and answer you anyway:

Yes, I asked other males what they've seen. You can't change reality. Our industry is about as male as the army. I could probably have counted the females in my computer science program back in college on one hand.

I'm just wondering if it really all is as behind closed doors/hidden as is implied, or perhaps I just haven't come across it. People talk. They meet up in bars. I hear all sorts of things from other people in the industry over FrieNDA - though I really haven't heard many stories like these.

Re:An open letter on feminism in tech by anildash on Thursday May 22, 2014 @03:06PM (#7785724)
Honestly wasn't trying to be snarky -- it may just come naturally. (Would also separately argue I'm not particularly well known on HN.)

If "our industry" is defined as the technology industry, it's actually far less male than the army; We just insist on not counting the women who frequently lead efforts around communications, corporate development, design, marketing, office management, and other essential parts of the business. And even within engineering-focused disciplines, there used to be far more women involved but the number has been going down in recent decades.

But the question all of us men have to ask ourselves is: Why do you need another source. You had a whole range of people already telling you what they saw, and you're looking for people who by definition would have less information about this topic to provide their opinions. Why do you think that's the case?

Re:An open letter on feminism in tech by rjknight on Thursday May 22, 2014 @04:23PM (#7786257)
It's not a question of sources, it's a question of being able to identify the thing when it happens. Women have no problem in identifying it, because it's directed at them. Men might have a problem identifying it, for various possible reasons. I think the poster you replied to was asking for opinions from other men about what they see happening in order to understand what kind of stuff is visible to men.

I have the same problem - I can't recall seeing anything that would qualify as harassment in any of my workplaces, and I would like to know if that's because I'm failing to see it, or if there's another reason.

Re:An open letter on feminism in tech by optimusclimb on Thursday May 22, 2014 @03:17PM (#7785801)
I edited my post (only to add, not change it.) After reflection, I think it was a little off base, even if well intentioned.
Re:An open letter on feminism in tech by anildash on Thursday May 22, 2014 @04:22PM (#7786247)
I appreciate the thought and reflection, especially given that my response could reasonably be seen as snarky.
Re:An open letter on feminism in tech by jsmthrowaway on Thursday May 22, 2014 @04:10PM (#7786166)
> (Would also separately argue I'm not particularly well known on HN.)

Because you're a single-issue commenter lately. You don't miss opportunities to jump in an HN thread about gender relations.

Re:An open letter on feminism in tech by makomk on Thursday May 22, 2014 @02:31PM (#7785443)
Why should he be less snarky? After all, the tech industry supposedly loves straight-talking engineers like Linus Torvalds who don't beat around the bush and tell people bluntly why they're wrong - so much so that we even let them get away with gratuitous personal insults and misguided arguments.
Re:An open letter on feminism in tech by davidgerard on Thursday May 22, 2014 @03:38PM (#7785946)
Whenever a geek says how much he loves unvarnished communcation, what he means is that he loves sending it - the same people regularly hit the roof when they receive it.
Re:An open letter on feminism in tech by mreiland on Thursday May 22, 2014 @04:30PM (#7786293)
There's a clear difference between a technical discussion and a social one. Do you think Linus is this way to everyone in every facet of his life?

context.

Re:An open letter on feminism in tech by dropit_sphere on Thursday May 22, 2014 @02:50PM (#7785579)
That's not the logic. It's more: "I'm an iOS user and every time an Android device is on the network my phone crashes." * "I use Android and have never seen this. Have any other Android users seen this?"
Re:An open letter on feminism in tech by mreiland on Thursday May 22, 2014 @04:21PM (#7786241)
And then someone replies with "yes, I have a co-worker who had the same issue, here's how we fixed it..."

The question is, would anyone tell them they couldn't possibly know that since they don't use IOS?

Re:An open letter on feminism in tech by worksaf on Thursday May 22, 2014 @02:25PM (#7785390)
When you understand why you dismiss my viewpoint so easily, you'll understand why I dismiss yours with the same ease.