News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Osmo by mikeash on Thursday May 22, 2014 @12:06PM (#7784506)
OK, seriously, why is it so hard for companies to just tell me what their product is?

I guess it's some sort of augmented reality thing? With a clip-on mirror? (???) And a standard Tangram game?

"For the first time, fun knows no limits." Did somebody redesign zombo.com for the 21st century and try to attach a product to it?

There are so many beautiful product pages out there which completely fail at the basic task of telling people what they're selling. It's baffling.

Re:Osmo by dragonwriter on Thursday May 22, 2014 @12:34PM (#7784685)
> There are so many beautiful product pages out there which completely fail at the basic task of telling people what they're selling. It's baffling.

Its not at all baffling. Selling product is about creating feelings of need for the product, not creating an accurate rational understanding of what the product does. There's a few markets (like marketing development tools to developers -- but, notably, not marketing developing tools to non-developer executives) where those two distinct issues happen to be somewhat (though not perfectly) aligned, but quite often they are unrelated or even opposed.

Video, as a medium, is very good at conveying desired emotional messages, and poor for conveying rational understanding (this is why, for decades, it has been observed that, that is, all other things being equal, watching more TV news makes you understand current events less, unlike consuming news in print media; it is also why video is a prime medium for advertisement.)

Re:Osmo by mikeash on Thursday May 22, 2014 @01:52PM (#7785161)
Do companies really try to create a feeling of need in people who don't even know what it is?

Certainly there's a ton of advertising out there that rests on "feeling of need", but it's always for stuff that everybody knows about. That subtle Rolex ad doesn't need to tell you "this device tells you what time it is wherever you go" because everybody already knows what a wristwatch is. Coca-Cola ads can focus on cute animated polar bears instead of "this is a carbonated sweet drink" because everybody knows their product. (Even then, they almost always show people actually drinking the stuff.)

If you have a new product, one that you're saying is different from anything else out there, surely you need to tell people what it is if you want them to think they need it.

Re:Osmo by thrownaway2424 on Thursday May 22, 2014 @01:22PM (#7784971)
"Fun with no limits" is a stick and a paper hat. Sometimes I wonder what other people's childhoods were like.

After reading their site and watching their video my chief question was whether this thing exists, or if you can preorder it and they'll start thinking about whether it's feasible or not, like many kickstarter-type things.

Re:Osmo by bstpierre on Thursday May 22, 2014 @01:53PM (#7785166)
> "Fun with no limits" is a stick and a paper hat.

This is what I came to say. This thing has a limit, and that is that you are tethered to the thing. And as an electronic thing, it is relatively fragile. You can't take it into the sandbox or a snow fort, and you can't get it wet or muddy. It looks a sit-at-a-desk toy, and that's just not a natural state for kids.

When I was a kid (and now that I watch my kids play), we were all over the place (backyard, woods, indoors, basement) and playing with all kinds of non-toys (sticks, rocks, couch-cushion-forts, and on rare & precious occasions a huge cardboard box or section of discarded pegboard) and putting toys together in unexpected ways (matchbox + lego; scraps of lumber + any toy => catapult; does every kid use their bike training wheels to prop up the bike in order to make rooster tails in puddles?).

For $60, I can buy a giant pile of stuff from the hardware store that we can use to make all kinds of "burglar alarms" (rube goldberg machines to ring a bell -- a favorite rainy day activity) that will involve a whole bunch more learning than anything like osmo can provide.

I'm somewhat biased towards being anti-technology, but it's really a bias against technology for technology's sake. This thing may be fun, and if that's what you want, go for it, but I can't really see that it's solving any particular problem per se.

Re:Osmo by lnanek2 on Thursday May 22, 2014 @02:13PM (#7785311)
I have no interest in watching to video either, but I can clue you in on the mirror's purpose at least. Normally the camera looks straight out at the user. They need the camera to look down at the table/floor/play surface. The on screen games depend on the app being able to see where you place each piece. Without the mirror the camera wouldn't be pointing at the pieces.
Re:Osmo by mikeash on Thursday May 22, 2014 @02:16PM (#7785333)
Thanks. I kept insisting on thinking that the mirror let it look back, which made no sense as there's already a camera back there.
Re:Osmo by bullfight on Thursday May 22, 2014 @12:07PM (#7784513)
This product definitely relies on the video to convey it's magic. If you don't watch the video, you won't get it.
Re:Osmo by mikeash on Thursday May 22, 2014 @12:11PM (#7784539)
I don't watch videos unless I'm first convinced by the text that they're worth watching. I doubt I'm alone in this. Why is it so hard to put one or two sentences that just tell me what you're talking about?
Re:Osmo by colbyh on Thursday May 22, 2014 @12:44PM (#7784740)
It's a safe bet that this product is not for you. Constructive comments are one thing, but anger over the fact that the value prop of a kid's game doesn't resonate with you is...awkward.
Re:Osmo by mikeash on Thursday May 22, 2014 @01:21PM (#7784961)
I"m not angry, although I am confused and mildly irritated that stuff keeps making it to the front page of HN where the page just doesn't tell you what it is.

As for the product not being for me, kids don't buy this stuff themselves. Their parents buy it. As the electronics-happy parent of a small child, I'm pretty sure I'd be right smack in the middle of the target demographic for this product if I had some clue of what it actually did.

Re:Osmo by colbyh on Thursday May 22, 2014 @07:05PM (#7787114)
That "confusion and mild irritation" is what I'm talking about. If you don't think their marketing page is up to your standards maybe constructive commentary based on your apparent demographic suitability would be a bit more helpful?
Re:Osmo by mikeash on Thursday May 22, 2014 @10:07PM (#7787667)
Reminding people that they need to remember to put in a couple of sentences describing the basic function of their product is constructive.

I didn't state it in a very friendly way, but that's a different issue.

Re:Osmo by SoftwareMaven on Thursday May 22, 2014 @12:40PM (#7784716)
That puts you in the vast minority of web users (I'm with you, fwiw). Given that, I wouldn't have any expectations that sites are going to tailor their experience to people like us. Video is used for these things because video works, and repeating in text what you showed in the video is repetitive for people who do watch the video.
Re:Osmo by yaddayadda on Thursday May 22, 2014 @12:26PM (#7784638)
mikeash, you are not alone. If text alone doesn't quickly and adequately convey what the product is or at least seriously pique my interest then I'm not going to spend time watching any videos.
Re:Osmo by wuliwong on Thursday May 22, 2014 @12:39PM (#7784714)
Are you guys serious? The giant picture of the child's hand on the puzzle and a picture of that same puzzle on the ipad didn't give you a clue??? I'm sure other people have trouble drawing meaning from images but I believe it is a small percentage.
Re:Osmo by mikeash on Thursday May 22, 2014 @01:22PM (#7784972)
It tells me that it has something to do with puzzles and augmented reality. But that's a pretty broad category, and the page doesn't narrow it down for me at all. It certainly doesn't tell me how it manages to make it so that "fun knows no limits."

If it's so clear to you, perhaps you could explain it instead of just making implicit insults?

Re:Osmo by kbenson on Thursday May 22, 2014 @12:22PM (#7784625)
There's probably also many people that won't bother reading much about the product, and are reached much easier through a video. In truth, their blurb There's digital gaming. There's real world fun. And then there's Osmo, a magical experience that merges the real and virtual worlds to defy the boundaries of play. is the few sentences you were looking for. It just appears to be useless marketing speech because their product isn't really a single thing, but a way to augment traditionally purely physical children's games with instant digital feedback. Than can be hard to explain in a useful way with just text.

Edit: s/new interaction mode for children/better description/

Re:Osmo by mikeash on Thursday May 22, 2014 @01:24PM (#7784976)
I'm skeptical that any product can be hard to explain in a useful way with just text. What exactly do you do with it? What's an example use case? What's the mirror for? All of these things can be answered in text.

However, given that I don't understand what it does, perhaps I'm not qualified to say that here.

Re:Osmo by kbenson on Friday May 23, 2014 @01:59PM (#7790469)
You didn't ask for just text, you asked for one or two sentences. I don't think this product can't be explained through text, just that it's a case where a very small amount of text will not do it justice, and may do more to confuse people than help.
Re:Osmo by User9812 on Thursday May 22, 2014 @01:27PM (#7785002)
It's one of those trick sites, where you never realize you can scroll down (thank you fullscreen image trend). Go back to the site, scroll. First thing you'll see...

Setup is a snap. Simply mount Osmo over your iPad's front‑facing camera. Reflective Artificial Intelligence and a built‑in mirror recognize and respond to your every real‑world move.

Then it goes on to describe the available games, and has other key information that's well summarized. I watched the video, and didn't realize you could scroll until I read your comment, and went back to the site a second time.

Re:Osmo by mikeash on Thursday May 22, 2014 @01:36PM (#7785050)
I scrolled all the way down, but nothing tells me what it is. I didn't watch the video, though.

The bit you quoted raises more questions than it answers. Why is there a mirror? What the hell is "reflective artificial intelligence"? What does it do with the recognition of your real-world moves?

Re:Osmo by User9812 on Thursday May 22, 2014 @01:44PM (#7785104)
I thought that was self-explanatory. Your iPad camera faces forward, the mirror redirects it down to the playing surface. The AI tries to track the location of the letters and colored blocks in the mirrored image.

What does it do? The examples are pretty obvious, what more are you looking for?

Arrange tangible puzzle pieces into matching on‑screen shapes.

Be the first to guess and spell out the on‑screen hidden word by tossing down real‑life letters faster than your friends. A related picture gives the clue.

Re:Osmo by mikeash on Thursday May 22, 2014 @01:54PM (#7785173)
Maybe the problem is just that what it does is so far removed from the superlative language used to describe the product as a whole? The introduction leaves me with the impression that it must be more than a silly augmented reality puzzle game.

I still don't understand the mirror. iPads have a camera in the back already....

Re:Osmo by User9812 on Thursday May 22, 2014 @02:09PM (#7785272)
http://i.imgur.com/0OXmc9h.png

The blue line is an iPad, the red region is the camera line of sight. On the left, you have no mirror, the camera is looking straight ahead at you. On the right, a mirror is attached, it redirects the camera view down to the playing surface.

Re:Osmo by mikeash on Thursday May 22, 2014 @02:18PM (#7785348)
Got it, thanks. Nice diagram. I can't help but think that if the connection between the iPad and the stuff in front of it was made a bit more clear on the site, as you have done, that it would be much easier to understand. Or maybe it's just me.
Re:Osmo by danielweber on Thursday May 22, 2014 @02:02PM (#7785219)
It's not understandable without the video.

(I'm not taking sides here on what should or shouldn't be expected on a website.)

Re:Osmo by mikeash on Thursday May 22, 2014 @02:17PM (#7785341)
People are saying that, but I'm skeptical. Language is pretty versatile. If Wikipedia can explain the concept of an ergosphere to me without video, surely it can be done for somebody's iPad game.
Re:Osmo by danielweber on Thursday May 22, 2014 @04:33PM (#7786302)
I meant, "the website is not understandable."

I believe the product is, platonically, understandable without a video.

PS: I like misusing the word platonically

Re:Osmo by mikeash on Thursday May 22, 2014 @04:54PM (#7786460)
That's kind of funny. "It's not understandable without the video" can be complete agreement or complete disagreement with what I'm saying depending on what "it" is. Stupid language.