Re:Show HN: PressureNet – The Weather's Future
by mturmon on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @04:19PM
(#7780535)
Thanks for the MWR reference. It's really great you've got people within that community so interested.
"...we've collected atmosphere data over a period of years, and we expect to find interesting climactic trends..."
Hmm, multi-year-scale trends in pressure data, as seen through a temporally-evolving sensor network subject to many kinds of extraneous variations (hardware changes, spatial sampling changes)? Color me skeptical on that one.
But that's typical HN "yes, but" skepticism. What you're doing sounds great and the case for weather is clear. Best wishes!
Here's a paper by Cliff and Luke regarding dense surface-level pressure observations: http://journals.ametsoc.org/doi/abs/10.1175/MWR-D-13-00269.1...
> I wonder if it's possible to quantify how much a perfectly-accurate ground-level pressure field could constrain upper atmosphere dynamics
Yes it is possible and we're working on this currently. There are some neat math techniques that we can use to estimate what kind of forecast accuracy increase we'll get with a dense network - but the only way to actually know is to scale up and start running experiments to find all the thresholds for improvements and diminishing returns.