Well, that's bullshit. I'm not endorsing Piketty, but you're making even less sense, unless there's a joke I've missed.
I do agree about unrestricted international immigration, such that there's a free flow of labor as well as capital. Unfortunately most people are mercantilist and opposed to the promulgation of global standards that would be required to make this work.
I'm not sure why you believe we need some sort of "global standards" for open borders to work. I'm undecided on the issue, but I can't see how "global standards" play a role.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_income_equ...
http://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/01/31/the-haves-and-t...
Anyway, as far as open borders go, the primary argument against them is that everyone will flood into those countries which have the most favorable conditions for workers, not just in terms of pay but in terms of safety, contractual rights and so forth. You would certainly want some sort of receiprocal arrangement, such that if people from China want to immigrate to the US, US people should be equally free to live, work and invest in China. You don't need to harmonize everything of course, but it's an incredibly difficult sell politically if you don't have reciprocity, on top of being an incredibly difficult sell because of mercantilist and xenophobic tendencies in the receiving economies. I'm heartily in favor of open borders and free trade in general, but most people hate the idea - even Tea Party types who profess a general disbelief in governmental competence.
India is a perfectly good example, since it illustrates that a relatively smooth wealth distribution doesn't mean you get a flush toilet. The caste system is still here, though nowadays it's more a social problem than an economic one.
Your discussion of harmonization sounds like countries need to harmonize to avoid competing with each other. What's wrong with competition, and allowing the better countries to get more workers?
This is obtuse even by your standards, Chris. You could equally well argue that South Africa with a Gini of 63 is enormously economically empowered, but you're not guaranteed a flush toilet there either.
What's wrong with competition, and allowing the better countries to get more workers?
Try being a politician explaining that to economically dislocated domestic voters. Hell, look how bent out of shape people here get about immigration and the US only ranks 180th out of the world in population density. I don't think it's it's an economic necessity, but it's a political reality, unfortunately.
I'm arguing only that inequality is orthogonal to what we really care about: standard of living. But discussing standard of living is a political loser - poor Americans have a very high standard of living, and the historical story is one of more or less consistent improvements.
(If you disagree, try this thought experiment: name a good or service people at the bottom lack.)
As for political reality you are correct. The fact that a few million rich Americans are jealous of their richer neighbors will always seem more important to politicians than hundreds of millions of truly poor people who can't vote for them.
I have no idea why people keep saying this about Piketty. You know that he's written on India quite a lot, both in the book and seperately where India is the sole subject of his work, e.g.: http://piketty.pse.ens.fr/fichiers/public/BanerjeePiketty200... as well as China: http://piketty.pse.ens.fr/fichiers/public/PikettyQian2009_AE...
In the book, I recall him only saying that he has no 200 year long timeseries. If someone can hadoop a wordcount, I'll bet that the word "Balzac" appears more frequently than "China". Any book which purports to discuss inequality, yet somehow ignores the inequality between France and India, is almost comically myopic.
I imagine Piketty would consider that a problem if he knew India existed.
If you want solutions for empowering those at the bottom, look to Bryan Caplan rather than Piketty.
http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2014/05/meant_for_each.h...