Re:Why people complain about the quality of Hacker News
by jacquesm on Friday August 21, 2009 @01:07PM
(#777959)
I think the bigger underlying problem is that HN forces those groups together without any kind of safety valve.
There is just the 'flag' option and that's about it. Whereas flagging normally is used to control spam but on HN it is used to control the topic of conversation. With a narrowly scoped site on-topic and off-topic are whatever people will use as a definition for those terms.
Here it seems that (and that's based on the current front page) a wide variety of subjects are perfectly ok for the homepage. And yet, in spite of that with some regularity there are discussions with 10's of upvotes and lots of people participating that get ruthlessly shut down. I don't think that proves that 'the system works'.
Enough ask PG and ask HN posts have been devoted to suggestions for improvements without so much as a rebuttal that I'm not holding my breath for change.
And telling people to leave in one way or another seems a very drastic solution, I'd basically conclude at that point that HN has failed.
I'm wondering how much of the resistance to improving the user experience on HN is grounded in arc, after all it is hardly a standard platform so every little bit of code has to be hand crafted for this one-off site.
PG has a lot on his plate (company, family) and probably has his hands more than full. This would explain the fact that his appearances here are relatively rare and that the development of the site is not keeping pace with the growth of the number of users.
Re:Why people complain about the quality of Hacker News
by po on Friday August 21, 2009 @01:30PM
(#778017)
I agree that the "flag" link is overloaded. I don't think I have ever flagged anything because I associate that with spam, not "opinions of people that I think are ruining the community"
There is just the 'flag' option and that's about it. Whereas flagging normally is used to control spam but on HN it is used to control the topic of conversation. With a narrowly scoped site on-topic and off-topic are whatever people will use as a definition for those terms.
Here it seems that (and that's based on the current front page) a wide variety of subjects are perfectly ok for the homepage. And yet, in spite of that with some regularity there are discussions with 10's of upvotes and lots of people participating that get ruthlessly shut down. I don't think that proves that 'the system works'.
Enough ask PG and ask HN posts have been devoted to suggestions for improvements without so much as a rebuttal that I'm not holding my breath for change.
And telling people to leave in one way or another seems a very drastic solution, I'd basically conclude at that point that HN has failed.
I'm wondering how much of the resistance to improving the user experience on HN is grounded in arc, after all it is hardly a standard platform so every little bit of code has to be hand crafted for this one-off site.
PG has a lot on his plate (company, family) and probably has his hands more than full. This would explain the fact that his appearances here are relatively rare and that the development of the site is not keeping pace with the growth of the number of users.