News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by josephschmoe on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @01:20PM (#7779443)
In the US, the quality of your math education is determined by where you live on the community level, usually by property value. Within 10 miles, you can have both a school that performs on par with Sweden and another that performs on par with Turkey.

What does this mean? Things are way worse for the poor here than this study even acknowledges. If you're poor in America, your best chance at a good education is by raffle.

Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by aurelian on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @01:37PM (#7779557)
Could this be explained in part by people who are good at math tending to make more money than people who are bad at math?

http://media.collegeboard.com/digitalServices/pdf/research/2...

Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by psychometry on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @01:53PM (#7779672)
If that's a component, it's a relatively insignificant one. Regression to the mean would likely take care of that advantage across generations.
Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by mikegioia on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @01:44PM (#7779602)
It has nothing to do with that. Wealth in this country is in no way correlated to math ability.
Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by nickff on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @01:55PM (#7779691)
Do you have any direct evidence of this?

I ask because it is well known that math ability is correlated with educational achievement, and level of education is known to be correlated with income. Putting these two together, I would suppose that math ability is correlated with income.

Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by mikegioia on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @02:05PM (#7779754)
I'm not saying that greater math ability doesn't correlate to greater wealth. That could very well be true (and it probably is). What I meant was that the public school system is funded by tax dollars. Wealthier neighborhoods contribute more tax money and have better public schools. I obviously don't have any direct evidence, but I would sat there's almost no correlation to wealthy neighborhoods and their residents being good at math. If you don't believe me, we could go knock on every door in my parents' neighborhood and ask them what they got on their SAT math section :P

Joking aside, I'm basing that on the fact that not every high-paying job requires math skills, and not every rich person got rich because of math.

Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by esbranson on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @08:21PM (#7781502)
Well, I think you're hitting on something.

1. I think you're wrong about the lack of correlation and, as nickff points out, better math ability is correlated with higher income, but

2. Math ability does not affect income.

Correlation is not causation. The better math ability is a side effect of higher income in my opinion, not vise-versa.

Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by aurelian on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @02:35PM (#7779924)
Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by mikegioia on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @03:22PM (#7780187)
What an annoying response. You link me an 18 page PDF and call it direct evidence? Did you even read what I said? I'm not arguing that greater math ability doesn't correlate to greater wealth! This issue boils down to wealthier neighborhoods getting more money to invest in better math education for their students. That's it! Are you claiming that all rich people are good at math? Or that only people good at math are rich? In your world, can there exist a neighborhood of wealthy people who are not good at math? I have no clue and frankly I'm done explaining myself here.
Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by aurelian on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @04:58PM (#7780736)
Your belief is wrong. All research on the subject tells us that spending has at most a small impact on test scores. I'd link you to PDFs but I know how you feel about that.
Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by esbranson on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @08:24PM (#7781510)
I think you're wrong, and that spending does have a huge impact on test scores; the PDF you link even supports that higher family income correlates with higher test scores. My argument assumes that wealthier families spend more than less wealthier ones.
Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by aurelian on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @09:07PM (#7781614)
The evidence is not on your side.

http://washington.cbslocal.com/2014/04/07/study-no-link-betw...

You can downvote me but you still have no evidence for your beliefs.

Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by esbranson on Thursday May 22, 2014 @07:53PM (#7787296)
I actually can't downvote you. And I wouldn't. Downvoting without responding is cowardly, or at least not conducive to the aim of a civilized discussion. Its the Hacker News equivalent to anonymous hate mail. They are like rumors, and lead to distrust and aversion to frank debate, everything we should try and avoid. If someone downvotes a comment that is ultimately upvoted, the downvotes should be reassessed against themselves or something. If Wikipedia had such a mechanism the whole community would break down. Its a bad feature.

School spending is not the only spending involved. A large cost, roughly equivalent to spending, of the family is that which is spent on providing a loving, supportive, positive, non-absent relationship within the family. This costs time away from work. This costs money cultivating relationships with intelligent people. This provides affluent children with more positive influences, positive role models, and less stress that lends to more focus on learning. They tend to invest more in their children, but its not to say that a wealthy family will invest as much as a poor family with more of a focus on education. The list goes on and on. Its not as if you need to be affluent to provide or invest in these things, its just more conducive.

Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by aurelian on Friday May 23, 2014 @12:28AM (#7787976)
I don't mean to be uncivil.

The claim that low-income students suffer because they are less likely to have families that enrich them is probably not as true as you seem to think.

http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2010/11/the_science_of.h...

Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by vraid on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @06:07PM (#7781047)
Incidentally, both Sweden and Turkey are ranked below the US average. Swedish education is in a sorry state at the moment, dropping fast in the rankings and already well below the level of any other nordic country.
Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by stillsut on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @01:47PM (#7779624)
Having gone to school in MA, I know educational spending ($/student) here is inversely correlated with performance.

But I'm not really worried about national average, state average, even school average: there just needs to be the opportunity to succeed for individual students, wherever they're located.

Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by noobermin on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @01:56PM (#7779696)
I think it is very much worth caring where the average is. This average person will grow up to become a voter and taxpayer and we need intelligent citizens to vote in competent representatives. Philosopher kings never happened, otherwise, just making sure the smartest get smarter would be okay; we have a democracy and the only way to make it work is to have informed citizens.
Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by maxerickson on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @05:38PM (#7780925)
Arbitrary education standards and comparisons to other countries aren't going to change the way people think.

(Implicit in the above is the opinion that for loads of national political issues, the biggest thing stopping "the masses" from being informed is that they simply don't care.)

Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by noobermin on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @01:41PM (#7779580)
I think the interesting thing was even middle class kids demonstrated poor performance too. The problem us spread wider across the distribution rather than abysmal performance by a minority such so that it pulled down the average (to me, that never really made sense in my intuition).
Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by josephschmoe on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @02:09PM (#7779778)
I definitely agree. There are some high-performing schools but they're a minority. There's also a minority of very, very low performing schools.

What makes us unusual is how wide the spectrum is, even if the average is bad.

Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by at-fates-hands on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @01:38PM (#7779559)
I totally agree and am depressed that places like inner cities have such a hard time getting more charter schools and competition that would give these kids and their families a shot at a decent education.

Is it politics? Teachers unions? Getting good admin people? What's holding back these places from getting ahead?

As a comparison, my sister lives on the outskirts of a large metro area and their school has been teaching STEM for almost 10 years now.

Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by zaphar on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @01:59PM (#7779712)
All of the above.

Politics is involved through school boards where an understanding of education is not really considered a job requirement. And at state and national levels it's difficult to fix problems that are uniquely local.

Teachers Unions can create the wrong incentives in a district.

Good Admin people are hard to find and bad ones make the working environment unplatable for good teachers.

Add in money as well for some districts.

Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by mikegioia on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @01:49PM (#7779638)
Honestly, the problem is a collection of so many problems that it's very difficult to really even assess the situation properly. It could be the overemphasis on standardized testing. It could be the lack of support teachers get in inner cities and the fact that they have to babysit 50% of the time. It could be the public school system's unwillingness to adapt. It could be the unions fighting tooth and nail to prevent more charter schools from opening. It could even be the charter schools not actually working!

Personally, I think the problem is that the public school system can't work well enough in poor areas. I think those children need a completely different education system to work for them (longer hours, after school programs, school uniforms!, etc).

Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by relaytheurgency on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @01:51PM (#7779658)
>What's holding back these places from getting ahead?

There is no motivation for someone to teach in inner cities beyond a sense of civic duty. I live in a city with terrible (unaccredited) schools. Students in those schools are often openly hostile to teachers and faculty. Administration is often on the verge of a breakdown due to the pressure to "turn things around." Why would anyone want to teach there? I know I didn't want to.

If you think it's a travesty that talented and bright teachers want to avoid inner cities then you should do it yourself. That's what I say to anyone who brings this up. Often I will be told, "But that's where you're needed!"

"So are you," is my response.

Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by at-fates-hands on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @03:21PM (#7780182)
This is probably one of the main things I did leave out, which is the socioeconomic toll of broken families, absentee parents and the lure of drugs and gang culture.

>>> If you think it's a travesty that talented and bright teachers want to avoid inner cities then you should do it yourself.

I can't argue with you there.

Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by Jtsummers on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @01:50PM (#7779643)
I'm curious what you mean by "teaching STEM", do you mean a particular emphasis on STEM? Because most schools at least cover the science and math part, with varying degrees on the technology and engineering (often limited by teacher availability and financial resources). If they don't cover those things then they aren't really covering any state's high school curriculum.
Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by at-fates-hands on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @03:16PM (#7780154)
Sorry, bad wording on my part. Yes, they have an emphasis on STEM. My niece is in 4th grade and they're already learning algebra, something I didn't start learning until 3-4 years later.

They also are learning about programming and other really technical stuff I was surprised to hear about. The other thing which was nice to hear is how they foster kids to learn and enjoy math - something I missed out on until I was in college and had a professor who really gave me a sense of how wonderful mathematics can be, not just a means to an end.

Re:US 'in denial' over poor maths standards by Florin_Andrei on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @02:02PM (#7779738)
Yeah, let's robo-blame the unions, that will inject some magic Ayn Rand juice into things and make everything better real quick. Sure.