Re:Scheme to become two languages
by andreyf on Friday August 21, 2009 @11:43AM
(#777726)
How can anyone think that deciding on expressions of computation should be done by committee? Imagine mathematicians were to get together to agree on standardized terminology for papers - what a waste of time it would be!
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Assuming you're not being facetious, I happen to think mathematics would be more advanced today if a little attention was paid to standardizing its notation:
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=733265
But don't take that as enthusiasm for committees.
Re:Scheme to become two languages
by RyanMcGreal on Friday August 21, 2009 @02:00PM
(#778078)
Almost no one is enthusiastic about committees. That doesn't make them any less of a necessary evil.
Re:Scheme to become two languages
by sandGorgon on Sunday August 23, 2009 @02:02AM
(#780268)
'''I happen to think mathematics would be
more advanced today if a little attention was
paid to standardizing its notation'''... as well as the tools available to render those notations.
That is exactly why one of the goals needs to be a small, understandable, core.
Committees degrade into uselessness when the discussion degrades into warring over features. Everyone has a pet feature, and nobody lets their pet feature go.
When you have a stated goal of minimalism (for at least part of the greater thing you're trying to define), then the argument to include this or that can be a /logical/ one based on whether it is actually /required/.
Re:Scheme to become two languages
by marcusbooster on Friday August 21, 2009 @12:41PM
(#777890)
It seemed to work fine for Haskell.
Really? There are still people who want a rewrite of Haskell's number types to organise it better (numeric prelude). Mainly for stuff like types that implement addition, but multiplication doesn't work for them.
And one would think that implementing math is easy ;)