News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I was forced to shut down Lavabit by tptacek on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @04:42PM (#7775058)
The way you arrive at that conclusion is to trust that no other Lavabit user was actually jeopardized by DOJ during their efforts to investigate Snowden's account. If you believe otherwise, then Levison's "retreat" imperils those users, presumably without their consent, in the service of Levison's own political objective.

I concede that that's a reasonable position to take. I think it's probably true that DOJ was unlikely to declare a field day on all of Lavabit, slurping every conceivable secret they could obtain from the service.

However we look at the situation, though, it seems unreasonable to accept deceptive statements from Levison about how it actually played out. His narrative doesn't square with the court's. What factual claim in the 4th Circuit ruling do you contend is false?

Re:Why I was forced to shut down Lavabit by jacquesm on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @04:51PM (#7775102)
I don't contend any of it is false. It may very well be true. But for Levison that doesn't matter. As was noticed in some other thread (possibly by you) courts are not in the business of finding the truth. So any kind of defence is fair game, including stalling, misdirection and so on. Don't judge a man if you're not in his shoes, he's lost everything that mattered to him already, and stands to lose a lot more still.

I'm not smart enough to set up a secure email service, but I would hope that if I did and I would be put under this kind of pressure that I'd be able to stall long enough that my users data would be as safe as circumstances still allowed and that the one the heat was applied to would be me. That's a damn sight better than rolling over at the first knock on the door and handing over all the data.

For sure he must have realized something important was up, who knows, he may have even read over Snowdens shoulder. I don't care either way, the man did his best. What happens after this is just silly vengeance, it will cost some money, a bunch of time, ruin one or more people's lives and the world will move on.

If there is one lesson to be learned here then it is that you should set up a service like this in such a way that it auto-destructs if you don't hit it periodically with some kind of signal that is not easy to fake without being you and that you advertise that fact and set the thing up in such a way that even you can't decode the data (and then you still have to hope that the NSA can't either in case they get a drive and/or a readout of your memory).

Re:Why I was forced to shut down Lavabit by saraid216 on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @06:15PM (#7775570)
> As was noticed in some other thread (possibly by you) courts are not in the business of finding the truth. So any kind of defence is fair game, including stalling, misdirection and so on.

I don't see the logical connection between these two sentences. Could you expand?

Re:Why I was forced to shut down Lavabit by jacquesm on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @06:20PM (#7775591)
The justice system seems to have become an instrument of revenge in some cases, bringing little or no reason to the way offenders are charged and punished. With a system that far off the rails it is perfectly ok for defendants to stop playing by the rules as well. That, I suspect is a good part of why Snowden is now living in Russia rather than taking his chances with the judicial arm of the USA, not because he's a coward. Cowards don't take action in the first place.
Re:Why I was forced to shut down Lavabit by saraid216 on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @07:21PM (#7775792)
Which cases are you thinking of, specifically? Is it specific to ones that are politically motivated?
Re:Why I was forced to shut down Lavabit by jacquesm on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @07:33PM (#7775835)
It seems to be mostly limited to those cases where the DOJ as an institution or some powerful individual in it has been made to look stupid, incompetent or both. I suspect the Aaron Swartz case was in part pushed as hard as it was because of the PACER stunt he pulled earlier, that Manning was not in solitary confinement for his own protection but as a means of exacting revenge and that there are other cases like these if you really start to look for them (which I didn't, two that I find plausible are enough for me).

The fact that Thomas raises the emotion flag in the top post in this thread makes the human element in the DOJ shine through quite a bit, to me that is a total-loss, if anything justice should be meted out with restraint and compassion. Not anger, revenge and furiousness. Those have no place in the justice department of a well organized society. Sure it is all people, but those people have a lot of power and should act accordingly.

Re:Why I was forced to shut down Lavabit by fit2rule on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @05:11AM (#7777266)
> there are other cases like these if you really start to look for them

Good luck with that. The US Government has its own firewall against control of this form, by its people.

Or, is there some reality TV show about Guantanamo and other associated criminal operations of the US around the world that I've missed?

In an environment where the government can remove the truth at will (with its formidable NSL weaponry), the battle is no longer about fair and equal society. Its a battle for justice, instead - and when all legal means of obtaining justice have been tied down by the "OMG! Terrorism!" crowd, the gloves need to come off. Citizens need to reign in their out of control government - otherwise they will become the (rightful) targets of the enemies that government is making ..

Re:Why I was forced to shut down Lavabit by saraid216 on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @11:10AM (#7778631)
AFAIK, the Manning case was and has been prosecuted entirely under military procedure, rather than involving the DOJ. I just woke up, so I am fuzzy and may have gotten that wrong.

> Those have no place in the justice department of a well organized society.

I'm not really sure what a "well organized society" means in this case. I don't get a general sense that we are a well-organized society, but I never have, so maybe that's just me.

While I agree that "revenge and furiousness" are wrong, I also see much less problem in anger. Anger has to be tempered by reason, sure, but that's what procedure is for, why good judges don't watch the news.