And under no circumstances would DOJ have had any way to verify the data they were given; they would have to trust that Levison would provide all the data they were looking for. Levison's complete knowledge of his own system might have furnished him with plenty of opportunities to employ technicalities to drastically curtail the information he provided to DOJ. And he had already established himself as an opponent of the investigation.
The terms Levison proposed were reaching. They were coupled with a monetary demand. Levison clearly didn't require the money to comply with the order; given Lavabit's architecture, it was straightforward for him to generate the information DOJ wanted. He asked for the money not because DOJ's demands financially jeopardized his service, but instead to stick a fork in DOJ's eye.
In the end, I feel very very unconfortable with the direction we are being taken by our governments.
Edit - that was coming over waaaay more aggressive than I meant -
He could have complied with the Article III specific warrant issued in accordance with Constitutional guidelines, just as he did for earlier warrants, instead of electing himself President of the United States and acting like he was above the law.
Where has this been covered? Also, is straightforward here being used interchangeably with "easy"?
And a critique of the design from Moxie Marlinspike: http://www.thoughtcrime.org/blog/lavabit-critique/
The critique provides details about how relatively easily the server could obtain any information about an account and its contents.
If the government wants to make me work, to be their mole, should I not be compensated for it? And shouldn't the expectations of that work be clearly defined?
This seems like business/compliance 101 stuff, the easiest detail to rationalize away, and gets a lot more ink than it deserves.
I apologize for not being clear in my earlier comment: if he'd just asked for the monetary compensation, I expect he would have gotten it.