Re:An Interview with the Old Man of Floating-Point (1998)
by aidenn0 on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @12:33PM
(#7773479)
A few years ago, I had the opportunity to speak with someone who was involved in p754, and he claimed that Kahan took advantage of the fact that Kahan took advantage of the fact that a number of his students were on the committee to add unecessary complexity to the standard.
I offer this anecdote not because I necessarily believe it's true, but because I think it offers more perspective on just how acrimonious the arguments over things like gradual underflow were.
I'm not a CPU designer, and so I can't speak to the merits of the case, but I do note that to this day, a large fraction of embedded CPUs do not have hardware support for denormals, but rely on the OS to implement it in software. My intuition is that this is not due to it being intractible, but rather the FPU being an afterthought on a lot of embedded processors.
I offer this anecdote not because I necessarily believe it's true, but because I think it offers more perspective on just how acrimonious the arguments over things like gradual underflow were.
I'm not a CPU designer, and so I can't speak to the merits of the case, but I do note that to this day, a large fraction of embedded CPUs do not have hardware support for denormals, but rely on the OS to implement it in software. My intuition is that this is not due to it being intractible, but rather the FPU being an afterthought on a lot of embedded processors.