News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by zorbo on Monday May 19, 2014 @03:01AM (#7766065)
HTTPSB just isn't userfriendly enough for me. I run Adblock (not plus though) + Ghostery, and perhaps they use more memory and CPU, but if they do I've never noticed nor cared about it. Their userfriendliness is amazing though. HTTPSB randomly cripples sites, much like NoScript, and I really can't be bothered to deal with that anymore.

With Adblock + Ghostery I feel completely in control. If I want to enable the Disqus script on a single page for a single session, Ghostery easily lets me do that. HTTPSB makes that hard, or perhaps I'm missing something.

Case in point: When I tried to post this comment, I got a "Dead link: users don't match" error which went away when I disabled HTTPSB.

Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by jzelinskie on Monday May 19, 2014 @03:29AM (#7766155)
I think a lot of people get the opposite feeling. HTTPSB lets you see everything in the matrix and toggle what you want to show. If you want the carefree experience you can use this strategy[0] to unblock everything and only rely on the blocklists to which you subscribe. I currently use this method and I all I really want now is a block list for cookies (and one as good as Ghostery's list).

[0] https://github.com/gorhill/httpswitchboard/wiki/How-to-use-H...

Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by pandog on Monday May 19, 2014 @03:35AM (#7766176)
But I don't want to use a strategy, I want to click a button and have adverts blocked.
Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by Sprint on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:13AM (#7766292)
Then HTTPSB is not the right extension for you.
Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by nikolak on Monday May 19, 2014 @07:29AM (#7766906)
Then it should not be compared to adblock.
Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by josefresco on Monday May 19, 2014 @08:50AM (#7767124)
I don't follow this logic. Both do generally the same thing, but with different approaches. This to me would make a comparison of the two different approaches very valid.
Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by pritambaral on Monday May 19, 2014 @07:51AM (#7766965)
That is not what is happening in the post. Only the filtering/element-hiding capabilities of both are being compared.
Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by Karunamon on Monday May 19, 2014 @09:57AM (#7767404)
That is exactly what is happening in the headline, however.
Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by TheLoneWolfling on Monday May 19, 2014 @09:02AM (#7767172)
You are calling HTTPSB an alternative for Adblock Plus.

One of the major use cases of Adblock Plus is effectively "Fire and Forget" mode - enable it and then don't worry about it.

You are saying HTTPSB does not support this use case.

As such, I don't see why you can call it an alternative to Adblock Plus.

Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by Justsignedup on Monday May 19, 2014 @01:26PM (#7768609)
It is an alternative. to all of like 1000 people worldwide who are willing to figure it out. So basically fire-and-forget mode, or broke.
Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by pessimizer on Monday May 19, 2014 @01:55PM (#7768783)
That's like saying that walking isn't an alternative to driving because there's no wheels. It's different, has a superset of functionality, and a different interface. It isn't a fork of ABP.
Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by TheLoneWolfling on Monday May 19, 2014 @05:33PM (#7769870)
It does not have a superset of functionality.

Adblock Plus / Edge has a "Fire and Forget" mode, as I described in my grandparent comment. HTTPSB does not. Hence, HTTPSB's functionality is not a superset of Adblock Plus/Edge's functionality.

Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by Justsignedup on Monday May 19, 2014 @02:46PM (#7769050)
Walking from New York to California to transport 15 tons of perishable cargo VS driving a truck with a refrigeration unit.

Your analogy fails.

Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by Executor on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @04:33PM (#7775001)
Your analogy fails too. I use a manual javascript blocking add-on (noscript) instead of an automatic blacklisting one and its not a deal-breaker. Minor effort required.
Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by gorhill on Monday May 19, 2014 @11:11AM (#7767790)
Well the article was specifically to challenge the claim that the problem of ABP memory consumption was mostly residing with Firefox.

But in any case, regarding your point, you can set up HTTPSB as an ad blocker and forget about it:

https://github.com/gorhill/httpswitchboard/wiki/HTTP-Switchb...

Advantage over ABP is that it discloses to you what is still not blocked, and you act on this information if you wish so.

Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by doczoidberg on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:17AM (#7766312)
I first had problems with it too. You have to disable matrix filtering on all sites.
Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by andreasvc on Monday May 19, 2014 @05:56AM (#7766604)
Is the extension equivalent to a /etc/hosts file at that point?
Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by doczoidberg on Monday May 19, 2014 @05:58AM (#7766606)
I don't know /etc/hosts

You can block specific things like iframes on domains.

Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by andreasvc on Monday May 19, 2014 @06:13AM (#7766650)
It's a very simple method that can prevent hostnames from resolving; see http://someonewhocares.org/hosts/zero/

Compared to other adblocking methods it's fast and does not use a lot of memory, but it's limited in what it can block (namely connections to specified hostnames).

Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by idlewan on Monday May 19, 2014 @03:41AM (#7766197)
You can allow everything by default too with HTTPSB (it still will use blocklists and protect you), so that you won't have to enable stuff for a website to work.
Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by nkvoll on Monday May 19, 2014 @05:00AM (#7766459)
I've been clicking around its user interface for a few minutes now, but I can't figure out how to do this..

Is it adding "whitelist *" somewhere or something similar?

Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by nkvoll on Monday May 19, 2014 @05:13AM (#7766499)
Seems like it was the power-button looking icon found in the upper left part of the extension dropdown menu when on an actual page.

I expected this to be a part of the extension settings / options, but ah well.

Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by gorhill on Monday May 19, 2014 @11:26AM (#7767880)
The power button is what I call "hard" allow all, i.e. it turns off completely matrix filtering.

The "all" cell (top left corner of the matrix) is a "soft" allow all, i.e. it allows everything except those hostnames and types of request which are not specifically blacklisted.

Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by u124556 on Monday May 19, 2014 @11:20AM (#7767843)
I think the point is they can port the code back to ABP so it can benefit from it. It's not a competition.
Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by sabret00the on Monday May 19, 2014 @05:34AM (#7766548)
Sorry to be slightly off-topic, but since you mention NoScript and are familiar with that, this (HTTPSB) and ABP, can I ask. Is HTTPSB more of a NoScript alternative or an ABP alternative?
Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by zorbo on Monday May 19, 2014 @07:00AM (#7766824)
From the little experience I have with HTTPSB, I'd say that it was more of a NoScript alternative. It feels to me like a webbrowser firewall. They seem to have moved into the adblocking field now though. Here's how I see it:

* Adblock (Plus): Blocking ads, No / minimal user action required

* NoScript: Blocking scripts. Lots and lots of user action required.

* Ghostery: Block privacy intrusions. Basically an application-level firewall for the browser. In a normal firewall, you'd block e.g. port 80 from IP x.x.x.x. In an appliction firewall you simply block, for instance, bittorrent traffic. Minimal user interaction required, and where it is required, it's very easy to use.

* HTTPSB: A low-level web browser firewall ("block port 80 from IP x.x.x.x) that now also does (better) adblocking. The adblocking is on par with Adblock (plus): no user action required. The browser "firewall" is basically unusable. Lots of user interaction required, and when it is required, it's basically impossible to understand.

Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by Justsignedup on Monday May 19, 2014 @02:48PM (#7769064)
Sounds a lot like we need some volunteers to build a better UI for simple (adblock mode), a 2nd option to do a noscript equivalent, and a 3rd option for wild-west-browser-firewall mode.
Re:Show HN: Where Adblock+ injects 20K CSS rules, HTTPSB inj... by beagle3 on Monday May 19, 2014 @07:13AM (#7766860)
I have the impression it's mostly a RequestPolicy replacement; but not using Chrome I haven't actually had a chance to use it.