News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Enclosed tube maglev system tested in China by dnautics on Monday May 19, 2014 @12:31AM (#7765715)
Atmospheric drag absolutely is a liability... That's the whole point of an evacuated maglev.. To make an artificial atmosphere with lower drag. Note how the mockdown chassis cross section is small relative to the tube... That's also a drag limitation; and note how hyper loop has a nearly full tube cross section.
Re:Enclosed tube maglev system tested in China by dojomouse on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:22AM (#7766332)
Sorry, I didn't word that very clearly - yes it's a liability, but it's a liability that's fairly independent of the levitation mechanism. I think it's more clear to say "That's the whole point of evacuated tube transport, to make an artificial...". Whether you use wheels or maglev or air bearings is a separate issue. Hyperloop doesn't turn the atmospheric drag into an asset - it just uses a particular method of overcoming the large liability. Because of how it overcomes it, it might be able to get away with a higher blockage ratio, but to say that with any real confidence you need to specify the vacuum level in the high-vac example you're comparing it to. And then do a bunch of compressible flow math that I've not yet seen for a high-vac ETT. This paper (http://jmt.swjtu.edu.cn/EN/abstract/abstract8587.shtml) looks at the incompressible flow case... but that's kind of missing the point I think.