Reminds me of a story (no idea about historical accuracy): When the chief propagandist of the UDSSR was invited to a scientific conference he talked about all the positive effects of socialism, how it will solve all problems and so on. When his talk was finished the scientists unsurprisingly questioned him about his talk, because of all the prominent problems with socialism. His answer was simple:
"The system is perfect. The people are the problem."
If your system is 'perfect', but the people are the problem, maybe your system is shit. No one would use an engine that could go near the speed of light but killed all passengers in the process.
I don't know what sort of shitty engineers you hang out with. Blaming users is not an option for engineers who design cars or airplanes or buildings. If 75% of pilots push the wrong button, the pilots aren't shitty, your cockpit design is shitty.
I think there's certain axioms one has to accept when it comes to weight loss. First of which is to lose weight, you will feel hungry. There is no diet that can avoid this. Billions of years of evolution have worked to ensure that we feel hungry when we're losing weight.
Diets fail because humans are supposed to feel hungry when they're dieting. No matter what the constraints of the diet are, no matter how much they advertise "you can feel satisfied as long you stick with foods X, Y, and Z", your body cannot be tricked into thinking it's satiated when it's not.
At some point, trying to think of this from an engineering standpoint breaks down, because you're solving an intractable problem. Humans really are the issue here.
I think we need to redefine diets as not a list of foods to eat or rules to follow, but instead a state of mind you have to have. An acceptance that you'll feel hungry, but it's worth it to be healthy or look good. It's actually kind of obvious when you think about it.
Thinking like an engineer, one should ask the question that is our underlying assumption, that is: is a calorie a calorie. The truth is, there are good calories and bad calories, and by eating good calories (fat, fiber, and protein) instead of bad calories (sugars and other non-fiber carbohydrates) you can lose weight.
Now if you are eating 1500 extra calories a day then your body burns, then switching diets is not the only answer, but for most people this isn't the case.
The corollary of this is that if you're running a sufficient enough deficit, it doesn't matter how "bad" the calories are, thermodynamics plays the dominant role:
http://calorielab.com/news/2010/11/20/twinkie-diet-results/
But in reality there's a lot more to "health" than just weight, so take it with a grain of salt.
THAT's thinking like an Engineer.