News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by magila on Friday May 16, 2014 @07:06PM (#7758421)
Putting broadband internet on the same level as electricity and water seems absurd to me. By far the most common use cases for broadband are streaming video, gaming/DLC, and piracy. Is there really a point where it becomes reasonable to consider Netflix, Xbox live, and The Pirate Bay essential services?
Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by imgabe on Friday May 16, 2014 @07:15PM (#7758453)
"Most common use cases" by volume of traffic maybe, but Internet is increasingly necessary to pay bills, correspond with customer service for practically any company, communicate with your child's teacher at school, renew your driver's license, and practically any other mundane task.

It's not that there aren't offline alternatives for these, but they require maintaining an expensive infrastructure of buildings and people. It's going to be cheaper for everyone in the long run if we can move everybody to doing things over the Internet.

Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by magila on Friday May 16, 2014 @07:58PM (#7758639)
None of those require broadband (2 Mb or greater according to the FCC, IIRC) though. We're talking about fiber connections in the hundred to thousand megabit range here. Nobody is talking about cutting poorer neighborhoods off from the internet completely.
Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by seanc722 on Friday May 16, 2014 @08:41PM (#7758778)
Seems pretty short sighted. There is so much being created that is connected to the internet. You say you don't need high bandwidth for these things and I would say that is because they are made with the fact that there are a lot of customers who don't have the higher bandwidth. Give everyone more bandwidth and just think of what we could create!
Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by pdonis on Friday May 16, 2014 @09:27PM (#7758898)
> None of those require broadband (2 Mb or greater according to the FCC, IIRC) though.

Really? Have you tried your bank's website over dialup? Or a typical bill pay site? (DSL typically meets the 2Mb or greater threshold, so it qualifies as broadband by your definition.)

Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by EvanAnderson on Saturday May 17, 2014 @10:45AM (#7760257)
I had 768/128Kbps DSL until last month (when my wife got fed up with poor streaming video quality and called the telco about upgrading). For using my bank, credit card company, and "social networking" sites it was fine. That's not dial up speed, I realize, but it's not 2Mbps, either. Since the upgrade to 7/1Mbps service I have observed that sites I thought were slow on the old service are still slow. My wife says YouTube and Hulu are better. I am pleased that my VPN to home seems better (which I attribute to the increased upload bandwidth).
Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by mschuster91 on Friday May 16, 2014 @08:33PM (#7758756)
It's either 56k or crappy DSL (2M) for these 'hoods, which equals a "cut off" these days in which everyone and their mother has a landing page with 2MB+ footprint.
Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by smsm42 on Saturday May 17, 2014 @04:28PM (#7760957)
It would be a good idea for the government at least to set the standard for their essential websites to not have 2MB+ footprint. As for the commercial ones, that would be for them to decide if they want larger audience or not.
Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by smsm42 on Saturday May 17, 2014 @04:16PM (#7760924)
You don't need Google fiber to send email or browse basic text site. Much better idea would be to force government sites that provide bill payments and other essential services (which 100% of them btw can be still paid by old fashioned phone call as far as I know) to have low bandwidth requirements and low compatibility reqs (i.e. no flash, no Java applets, no excessive graphics, etc.). This would also ensure better accessibility, but also would mean you never need 100M channel to just pay your bill.
Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by mullingitover on Friday May 16, 2014 @07:30PM (#7758500)
> By far the most common use cases for broadband are streaming video, gaming/DLC, and piracy. Is there really a point where it becomes reasonable to consider Netflix, Xbox live, and The Pirate Bay essential services?

Ah yes, you can use it for trivial things, so let's totally ignore all the crucial information and services that are only available on the internet. That seems reasonable.

Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by sltkr on Friday May 16, 2014 @07:48PM (#7758593)
So what are the “crucial information and services” exactly that require gigabit internet access (Google Fiber's selling point, after all) today?

Although “broadband” has always been a moving target, I think it is reasonable to say that essential services won't require gigabit internet access in the next decade or so.

Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by mullingitover on Friday May 16, 2014 @08:37PM (#7758767)
We won't know exactly what we can do with it until it's reached critical mass, just like with the telephone. Medical telepresence comes to mind.

> I think it is reasonable to say that essential services won't require gigabit internet access in the next decade or so.

And 640k should be enough for anybody.

Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by bsder on Friday May 16, 2014 @11:53PM (#7759176)
Bidirectional interactive video. Poor areas would benefit most from telepresence teaching.
Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by zo1 on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @06:17AM (#7771861)
Telepresence teaching for the poor? Are you actually serious? Rather just fix the schools, please. Instead of throwing money at a "problem" that you invented a need for.

I know as tech people we're inclined to think that more tech can always fix the world's problems. But that's a venus project type of fly-trap, and we must be careful not to fall for it!

Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by Larrikin on Saturday May 17, 2014 @10:10AM (#7760159)
Are they totally trivial things? Most poor people are working poor at jobs they don't particularly like. Should they be miserable at all times of the day just because they are poor?
Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by biff on Friday May 16, 2014 @07:19PM (#7758474)
As broadband becomes more pervasive I think we'll see other uses (for example, I could see VR being incorporated into virtual high schools for things like simulating a chemistry lab.)

How long did it take for electricity to be considered a necessity? And I'm legitimately curious how much of a factor radio was in motivating people to make the switch...

Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by qq66 on Friday May 16, 2014 @07:10PM (#7758433)
No, but I would argue that regular internet is approaching an essential service. Nobody needs FiOS but lots of people need access to email/web browser/etc.