Re:Why you shouldn't use the Lesser GPL for your next library
by tzs on Friday May 16, 2014 @06:43PM
(#7758339)
This is reminiscent of the RIPEM situation ~20 years ago. This was a program that did email encryption using RSA. RSA was implemented using a library from RSA (the company) that was freely distributable but not free software, and because RSA (the encryption method) was patented, there was no way in the US to replace this library with free software.
RIPEM also needed a big integer math library. The two main free software libraries for this were the GNU one and the the BSD one, which had different interfaces. RIPEM could be built to use either. This was an option you could set when you ran the build script.
The FSF said that distributing the RIPEM source code was a GPL violation, even though they did not claim copyright on any code in the RIPEM distribution. In particular, they were adamant that they were not claiming a copyright on the GNU mp library interface.
Their claim was that since RIPEM contained code (the conditional code that used the GNU mp interface) that was only useful with GNU mp, distributing that source code would lead to some people downloading GNU mp, which they would then link with RIPEM and the non-free RSA library, and that this meant that the RIPEM people had effectively distributed GNU mp with non-free software. See note [1].
The RIPEM people finally put an end to this nonsense by making a "new" mp library that had the same interface as the GNU mp library and was either (memory is hazy) just a thin wrapper for the BSD mp library, or was just a quick and dirty implementation of the simple, classical mp algorithms that any decent programmer can knock out from Knuth fairly quickly.
This meant that people receiving the RIPEM source and choosing to build using the GNU mp interface might not actually build with GNU mp. They might instead build with this new library. Now induced distribution can no longer be inferred. This satisfied FSF.
This was pretty astounding. If X is written first, and Y is written second, the answer to the question of whether or not Y infringes the copyright of X does not change if a third thing, Z, comes along AFTER X and Y. Copyright law obeys the arrow of time. :-)
[1] I may not be remembering their theory exactly correctly. The general outline (RIPEM not distributing any GPL code, but FSF thought they were liable anyway if someone downloaded RIPEM source, downloaded GNU mp source, and linked them together) is right.
RIPEM also needed a big integer math library. The two main free software libraries for this were the GNU one and the the BSD one, which had different interfaces. RIPEM could be built to use either. This was an option you could set when you ran the build script.
The FSF said that distributing the RIPEM source code was a GPL violation, even though they did not claim copyright on any code in the RIPEM distribution. In particular, they were adamant that they were not claiming a copyright on the GNU mp library interface.
Their claim was that since RIPEM contained code (the conditional code that used the GNU mp interface) that was only useful with GNU mp, distributing that source code would lead to some people downloading GNU mp, which they would then link with RIPEM and the non-free RSA library, and that this meant that the RIPEM people had effectively distributed GNU mp with non-free software. See note [1].
The RIPEM people finally put an end to this nonsense by making a "new" mp library that had the same interface as the GNU mp library and was either (memory is hazy) just a thin wrapper for the BSD mp library, or was just a quick and dirty implementation of the simple, classical mp algorithms that any decent programmer can knock out from Knuth fairly quickly.
This meant that people receiving the RIPEM source and choosing to build using the GNU mp interface might not actually build with GNU mp. They might instead build with this new library. Now induced distribution can no longer be inferred. This satisfied FSF.
This was pretty astounding. If X is written first, and Y is written second, the answer to the question of whether or not Y infringes the copyright of X does not change if a third thing, Z, comes along AFTER X and Y. Copyright law obeys the arrow of time. :-)
[1] I may not be remembering their theory exactly correctly. The general outline (RIPEM not distributing any GPL code, but FSF thought they were liable anyway if someone downloaded RIPEM source, downloaded GNU mp source, and linked them together) is right.