DRY. Just, DRY. If DRY leads you to MVC, rock on. But DRY is the real thing. It isn't a framework, and you have to think about it. But it's what you're really trying to do.
You're trying to define yourself the win by imputing to me a motivation to go "back" to crappy design. It's quite disingenuous, since I just got done complaining that MVC is often a crappy design, and logically concluding from that that I must want crappy designs is ludicrous once I call it out.
And if you further feel inclined to say "But you didn't give me an answer!", well, the need for "one" answer is part of the problem. There isn't one answer for which design structure will lead you to the DRYest design. Sometimes it'll be MVC. But you have to think. Not just knee-jerk MVC and think you've "designed".
People seem to think that if you dress software architecture up in the trappings of religious dogma, then it's easier to evangelize and recruit people to your cause. Well maybe they're right: it kind of worked for Larry Wall, for a while...
It usually turns out that there are more like 17 different essential concepts that you need to get a complex software project off the ground, but 17LAs like MVPATQSDYKRFXZFHW aren't as catchy, and are too hard to remember and pronounce, so they end up cramming everything that's not obviously M or V into the kitchen sink C.
DRY is great, but you should also DRTMOTP: Don't Repeat The Mistakes Of The Past!
Desktop app UIs were never this painful. Even Swing's.
Its tutorial (A walk on the seaside on http://seaside.st/documentation/tutorials) is rather basic, but shows the concepts well. (edit: longer article http://book.seaside.st)
Of course it has a different set of quirks to get used to, so it's not a cure-all - but it gives a different perspective on web-things.
I'd say anyone upset over MVC's leaky abstractions could better funnel that energy spent into making something better but I can't help to think that no software project is ever going to so neatly conform to having a structure imposed upon it.
That's the problem with prescribing an architecture ahead of time. That's why you learn the basics and improvise/draw on established architectures as the project evolves.
I'd take a crap MVC design over the pre-MVC stuff I worked on any day of the week.
The thing you don't seem to be saying is what you're doing instead? You're just waving hands at the moment and saying it's bad, but it used to be much worse.