And making the company is thus the important part. I would put "the next Linus Torvalds will not build an Operating System" in there too.
Secondly the next new thing has already been invented, it just has not been widely disseminated. James Watt did not invent the steam engine, but he embraced and extended it whilst building perhaps the first truly modern international company.
Whenever there is space for innovation and the incumbent does not react, a new player appears.
Facebook is my next to be toppled over bet. There is a huge space for innovation and FB is not nimble and quick to react nor it is particularly innovative on its own. Acquisitions and the social network barrier to entry protect FB, but they don't hold forever.
Facebook may reach that point before to long, although I'd guess they're not there yet.
Is it irrelevant that the examples fail to back up the assertion because Peter Thiel is the one making it?
The 'big idea' expressed in this blurb is that it's 'easier to copy a model than to make something new.'
And the supporting arguments show off the opposite case just to associate the book with becoming the next industry defining billionaire.
Whoever wrote this blurb is either not thinking clearly, or is banking on readers to not think clearly.
There are much better example cases for that argument, but they aren't as flashy.
I'd used both CP/M and Apple DOS before MSDOS - neither were exactly niche products back then. And Altavista was pretty well established as the best search engine before the Google upstart appeared.
As for social media, Myspace had 100 million users in 2006 and wasn't passed in popularity by Facebook until a couple of years later.
All of these things were entrants into well established markets which had (at the time) heavyweight incumbents. They've all become vastly more successful than those incumbents, but that's not because they were inventing or even popularising a concept. These weren't obscure concepts that these people took mainstream, and there have been/will be other hugely successful entrepreneurs in every single one of these areas at some point.
My point is that the author's claim that "You won't get rich, famous and powerful by building a better mousetrap. You can only do that by being the one person who creates or popularises a whole new market segment" is simply wrong and has been shown to be wrong time and time again - including by the very people he's using as examples.
Maybe my history is not that good, but as far as I know Bill gates didn't build the first operating system, and when he bought 86-DOS, its success was mainly thanks to IBM. Same for Google, it wasn't the first search engine, it just improved on an existing concept.