News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Any room in the startup world for an ideas man? by pbhjpbhj on Thursday August 20, 2009 @07:46AM (#774796)
"plans are great but executing them is where the work is [...]" True enough, but some people are good at execution and some people are good at ideas. During the execution phase you're going to need more ideas, probably, to get past your MVP and on to a fully rounded product. Reminds me of the postings the other on Word of Goo - the idea was simple, implementing it was quite hard but additional ideas were added all along the way: things that transformed the product.

Ideas possibly are ten-a-penny, good ideas ...? Great ideas restricted to a specific market segment, they've got to be even more rare. PageRank was a good idea, sure without implementation it's nothing, without the idea there's no implementation though.

Re:Ask HN: Any room in the startup world for an ideas man? by jacquesm on Thursday August 20, 2009 @08:22AM (#774839)
Yes, but just about everybody has ideas. I can't imagine that those that are good at execution do not have ideas.

The original 'apple' was an idea that many had at the time, two guys with the werewithal to go and execute that idea made it big. I'm sure that in the HCC of the time there were 100's if not 1000's of people that had the idea of a (cheap) computer for everybody.

People that have 'ideas' need to be aware of several really important things:

- everybody has ideas, pretty much all the time

- your idea is most likely not even original ("hey, I thought of that long ago!", yes, so?)

- it might be a great idea but it may never fly, to ask others to risk all to implement your idea for a substantial portion of equity while you risk nothing is out of balance.

- those people that 'had ideas' and made it big invariably were also good at execution.

People that 'just have ideas' usually end up in advertising or marketing where 'brain storm sessions' are their way of minting their idea motor, after all, there you get a salary for just having ideas.

The OP asked if there was room in a startup for an idea guy, the answer is really I don't think so, a startup needs one good idea, then execute it properly the rest is implentation. (Ebay : let's put an auction on the web, YouTube : Let's make it easy to post videos, facebook : let's do 'classmates' but much better). After that the execution takes over, that sort of idea you only need one of to have a viable business.

Sure, during the 'execution' phase you'll need more ideas, but those are usually not going to fundamentally change the nature of the business, unless the original idea wasn't very good...

In an incubator though, there is a place for an idea man. That's where there is added value, also if you're good at ideas you may be good at shooting down other peoples ideas before resources are wasted.

Re:Ask HN: Any room in the startup world for an ideas man? by netconnect on Thursday August 20, 2009 @08:53AM (#774904)
Thanks for the honest response(s). What is this incubator you mentioned? Could you tell me more or link to something that does?
Re:Ask HN: Any room in the startup world for an ideas man? by jacquesm on Thursday August 20, 2009 @08:54AM (#774906)
Well, news.ycombinator.com is the property of exactly such an institution but there are plenty more out there.

Seed capital funds are another possible avenue.

Re:Ask HN: Any room in the startup world for an ideas man? by netconnect on Thursday August 20, 2009 @09:21AM (#774965)
After a bit of a search around I understand this all much better. Not to mention have a sudden thirst to get involved with that kind of organisation.

I guess I will just release my little plans on HN and enjoy the feedback! Would love suggestions for other places to use my creativity for something worthwhile (for me or a community).