Re:Peer Review as a Service: It's not about the journal
by seanmcdirmid on Thursday May 15, 2014 @03:16AM
(#7748171)
That doesn't help with tenure committees. I guess in Astronomy, this is less of a problem, but in computer science, different fields of computer science are so different that those on your committee will have probably never have read what journal you are publishing to. They go by reputation alone.
I think this unique status will help OJA succeed - astronomers are already used to judging papers from all four journals with roughly equal weight. If some senior people get behind it and start making big, important papers available via OJA, I think it really might take off.
Page charges can be seriously expensive. I think many academics would be happy to avoid the whole mess and just post to the arxiv and get peer review via OJA. It's already more or less standard practice to post to the arxiv either upon submission or acceptance, this just formalizes that practice and adds an element of certification of the result.